Upper West Side Restaurants You Absolutely Need to Try
A Culinary Journey Through the Upper West Side
The Upper West Side: a culinary landscape where the echoes of old-world charm harmonize with the bold notes of modern flavors. This vibrant corner of Manhattan, known for its leafy avenues, cultural institutions, and a palpable sense of community, boasts a dining scene as diverse and captivating as its residents. From the comforting aroma of freshly baked bread wafting from neighborhood bakeries to the sophisticated ambiance of acclaimed restaurants, the Upper West Side offers a gastronomic journey for every palate.
Home to Lincoln Center, the American Museum of Natural History, and a host of other cultural landmarks, the Upper West Side is more than just a residential area; it’s a cultural hub that attracts a diverse and discerning crowd. And with that diverse crowd comes a craving for equally diverse culinary experiences. Forget endless scrolling and overwhelming choices, because this is your ultimate guide to experiencing the best of the Upper West Side food scene.
From cozy neighborhood gems cherished by locals to acclaimed fine-dining establishments celebrated city-wide, we’ve meticulously curated a list of the Upper West Side restaurants that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Drawing upon a combination of glowing reviews, the unwavering loyalty of local foodies, the restaurants’ rich history, prestigious awards, and our own firsthand experiences, we present to you the definitive compilation of Upper West Side culinary must-tries. Prepare to embark on a delicious adventure through the heart of New York City, one unforgettable bite at a time.
Zabar’s
Cuisine Type: Deli/Market
Address: Broadway
Zabar’s isn’t just a store; it’s a legendary Upper West Side institution, a gastronomic haven overflowing with culinary delights. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a symphony of sights and smells: the glistening smoked fish, the seemingly endless array of cheeses, the perfectly arranged fruits and vegetables, and the comforting aroma of freshly baked bread.
Why It’s a Favorite: Zabar’s is more than just a place to buy food; it’s a cultural experience. Their rugelach is undeniably addictive, and simply browsing the aisles is an adventure in itself. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or a curious newcomer, Zabar’s is a must-visit destination on the Upper West Side. You can grab a quick bite from their deli counter, stock up on gourmet ingredients, or simply soak in the atmosphere of this iconic establishment. It’s a true testament to the enduring appeal of quality, tradition, and community.
Price Range: Depends on what you buy
Barney Greengrass
Cuisine Type: Jewish Deli
Address: Amsterdam Ave
Often hailed as “The Sturgeon King,” Barney Greengrass is a testament to the enduring appeal of classic Jewish deli fare. Stepping inside is like stepping back in time, with its traditional decor, bustling atmosphere, and the comforting aroma of smoked fish and freshly baked bagels. This Upper West Side landmark has been serving up some of the best sturgeon in the city for generations, earning a loyal following of locals and tourists alike.
Why It’s a Favorite: For a truly unforgettable experience, order the classic sturgeon sandwich, piled high with thinly sliced fish and served on a toasted bagel. Alternatively, explore their vast selection of breakfast platters, laden with smoked salmon, cream cheese, and all the traditional accompaniments. A single visit to Barney Greengrass is enough to set you up for the entire day, energized by the rich flavors and the warm, welcoming atmosphere. It’s a must-try for anyone seeking an authentic taste of New York City’s Jewish deli heritage. This Upper West Side establishment always delivers a unique culinary experience.
Price Range: Moderate
Carmine’s
Cuisine Type: Italian
Address: West Forty-fourth Street
Prepare for a feast at Carmine’s, the family-style Italian restaurant that promises to impress. Known for its generous portions and lively atmosphere, Carmine’s is the perfect place to gather with friends and family for a truly memorable dining experience. The restaurant’s vibrant energy and classic Italian decor create a welcoming ambiance that makes you feel right at home.
Why It’s a Favorite: The incredible atmosphere and family style setting that really makes you feel welcome. Not to mention the giant portions of delicious Italian classics. From the iconic spaghetti and meatballs to the decadent chicken parmesan, every dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and a generous helping of love. This is a place for sharing, for laughter, and for creating lasting memories around the table. If you’re looking for a taste of authentic Italian hospitality and a culinary experience that’s both satisfying and unforgettable, Carmine’s is a must-visit destination on the Upper West Side.
Price Range: High
Cafe Luxembourg
Cuisine Type: French
Address: West Seventieth Street
Transport yourself to the heart of Paris at Cafe Luxembourg, a sophisticated French brasserie that exudes timeless elegance. With its classic decor, warm lighting, and impeccable service, Cafe Luxembourg is the perfect setting for a romantic dinner, a special occasion, or simply a night out with friends.
Why It’s a Favorite: The restaurant is known for its perfectly executed French classics, from the delicate escargots to the rich and flavorful steak frites. The wine list is extensive, and the knowledgeable staff is always on hand to offer recommendations. Whether you’re craving a taste of France or simply seeking a refined dining experience, Cafe Luxembourg is a must-visit destination on the Upper West Side. It’s a wonderful place to celebrate special occasions.
Price Range: High
Jacobs Pickles
Cuisine Type: American Comfort Food
Address: Amsterdam Avenue
If you’re craving comfort food with a twist, look no further than Jacob’s Pickles. This Upper West Side favorite is known for its creative takes on classic American dishes, with a particular emphasis on, you guessed it, pickles. From fried pickles to pickled vegetables to pickle-brined chicken, there’s something for every pickle lover at Jacob’s Pickles.
Why It’s a Favorite: Jacob’s Pickles is more than just pickles, however. The menu also features a wide variety of other Southern-inspired dishes, such as mac and cheese, biscuits, and fried chicken. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal. Whether you’re a pickle enthusiast or simply looking for a comforting and satisfying meal, Jacob’s Pickles is a must-visit destination on the Upper West Side.
Price Range: Moderate
Shake Shack
Cuisine Type: Burgers
Address: Various Locations on the UWS
A New York City staple, Shake Shack has multiple locations on the Upper West Side. While it’s a chain, it’s a beloved one for its delicious burgers, crinkle-cut fries, and creamy shakes.
Why It’s a Favorite: It’s a reliable and tasty option for a quick and casual meal. The burgers are juicy, the fries are perfectly crispy, and the shakes are decadent. It’s a classic for a reason. Shake Shack also offers vegetarian options.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
Gray’s Papaya
Cuisine Type: Hot Dogs
Address: Broadway and West Seventy-second Street
Another iconic New York City experience, Gray’s Papaya is known for its cheap and delicious hot dogs and refreshing papaya juice.
Why It’s a Favorite: It’s a quintessential New York experience and great for a quick and satisfying bite on a budget. It’s a local favorite and a must-try for tourists.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
Good Enough to Eat
Cuisine Type: American Brunch
Address: Amsterdam Avenue
This cozy spot is famous for its delicious and comforting American brunch classics.
Why It’s a Favorite: They have a cult following for a reason. They create the most incredible comfort food brunch meals. It is also kid friendly, and a great spot for tourists as well.
Price Range: Moderate
Isabella’s
Cuisine Type: Mediterranean
Address: Central Park West
Located near the Museum of Natural History, Isabella’s offers a Mediterranean-inspired menu in a sophisticated setting.
Why It’s a Favorite: It’s a great spot for a meal after visiting the museum or exploring Central Park. They have a beautiful outdoor seating area and a diverse menu with something for everyone.
Price Range: Moderate
La Caridad
Cuisine Type: Dominican
Address: Amsterdam Avenue
A neighborhood staple, La Caridad is known for its authentic and affordable Dominican cuisine.
Why It’s a Favorite: It’s a great place to experience the flavors of the Dominican Republic without breaking the bank. The portions are generous, and the food is flavorful and satisfying.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
Awadh
Cuisine Type: Indian
Address: Broadway
Awadh offers a refined take on traditional Indian cuisine.
Why It’s a Favorite: This is a lovely spot for those looking for high quality indian cuisine. The restaurant is also beautiful and the service is great.
Price Range: Moderate
Playa Bowls
Cuisine Type: Acai Bowl
Address: Various
Healthy choice for Acai bowls.
Why It’s a Favorite: It has become a neighborhood staple, and will provide a healthy alternative.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
P.J. Clarke’s
Cuisine Type: American
Address: Columbus Avenue
This American Restaurant has amazing burgers.
Why It’s a Favorite: Great burgers and casual atmosphere. It also has a very lively bar scene.
Price Range: Moderate
Thai Market
Cuisine Type: Thai
Address: Amsterdam Avenue
Great Thai Restaurant.
Why It’s a Favorite: Delicious Thai Food and Great Prices. A really popular spot.
Price Range: Moderate
Alice’s Tea Cup
Cuisine Type: Tea
Address: West Seventy-third Street
If you are looking for a fancy tea party, this is the spot for you.
Why It’s a Favorite: Its one of a kind atmosphere is extremely rare. Its a fun place for family and friends.
Price Range: Moderate
Arte Cafe
Cuisine Type: Italian
Address: Columbus Ave
Upscale Italian cuisine that is worth it.
Why It’s a Favorite: They have incredible dishes, and is very upscale. It’s a good choice for special events.
Price Range: High
Boat Basin Cafe
Cuisine Type: American
Address: West Seventy-ninth Street
If you are looking for some outdoor dining, this is the spot for you.
Why It’s a Favorite: Gorgeous views and outdoor eating.
Price Range: Moderate
Amelie
Cuisine Type: French
Address: Amsterdam Ave
Amelie is a french cuisine restaurant with amazing quality food.
Why It’s a Favorite: Another great french cuisine spot. This is a hot spot in NYC.
Price Range: Moderate
Osteria Cotta
Cuisine Type: Italian
Address: Columbus Ave
Amazing Italian cuisine in a busy environment.
Why It’s a Favorite: Amazing Italian dishes, one of the best in NYC.
Price Range: Moderate
Pomodoro
Cuisine Type: Italian
Address: Columbus Ave
Italian restaurant that is known for their pizza.
Why It’s a Favorite: Great pizzas, and a cute place for dates.
Price Range: Moderate
Dig Inn
Cuisine Type: Health Food
Address: Various
For all the healthy food lovers, Dig Inn is for you.
Why It’s a Favorite: For a quick bite of great quality food, Dig Inn is for you.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
Bluestone Lane
Cuisine Type: Australian Coffee Shop
Address: Various
Known for their delicious coffee, this is a great cafe.
Why It’s a Favorite: Great coffee and a cute coffee shop atmosphere.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
West Side Restaurant
Cuisine Type: Diner
Address: Broadway
For late night eats, this diner is a must.
Why It’s a Favorite: Great option for late night dining, especially a hangover.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
Hungarian Pastry Shop
Cuisine Type: Dessert
Address: Amsterdam Ave
This is a neighborhood spot for all types of pastries.
Why It’s a Favorite: So many great pastries at a fair price. A great spot to eat something sweet.
Price Range: Budget-Friendly
A Taste of the Upper West Side
The Upper West Side’s culinary scene is a reflection of its vibrant and diverse community. From classic delis to innovative restaurants, the neighborhood offers a wide range of dining experiences to suit every taste and budget. The restaurants listed above offer a taste of the neighborhood’s heart and soul. Whether you’re a longtime Upper West Side resident or a visitor, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
So, which Upper West Side restaurant is your favorite? Share your recommendations and experiences in the comments below! We encourage you to embark on your own culinary exploration of the Upper West Side, discovering new favorites and rediscovering old classics. After all, the best way to experience a neighborhood is through its food. The Upper West Side promises a culinary adventure that will leave you wanting more. So, what are you waiting for? Grab your appetite and explore the diverse culinary landscape of the Upper West Side today!
