Upper West Side Eats: Our Twenty-Five Favorite Restaurants

Introduction

The Upper West Side. Just the name evokes images of leafy streets, grand pre-war buildings, and a distinctly New York City charm. More than just a residential haven and cultural hub, the Upper West Side is a neighborhood that understands good food. From cozy cafes tucked away on quiet side streets to bustling bistros on Amsterdam Avenue, the Upper West Side dining scene is a diverse tapestry of flavors, experiences, and culinary traditions. But with so many choices, where do you even begin? That’s why we’ve curated a list of twenty-five of the most beloved restaurants on the Upper West Side. These aren’t just any eateries; they’re the places locals swear by, the spots that consistently deliver delicious meals and memorable moments. We considered everything from exceptional cuisine and consistent quality to ambiance and value, and of course popularity, to give you the ultimate Upper West Side dining guide. Get ready to embark on a culinary adventure through one of New York City’s most iconic neighborhoods.

Classic Italian Flavors

The Upper West Side boasts a rich Italian heritage, reflected in its array of exceptional Italian restaurants. Here are some of our favorites:

Carmine’s

Picture this: massive platters of pasta, overflowing bowls of mussels, and the aroma of garlic and oregano filling the air. That’s Carmine’s, a family-style Italian institution on Broadway. Known for its generous portions and lively atmosphere, Carmine’s is the perfect place to share a meal with friends and family. Be sure to order the signature pasta dishes and be prepared to take some home. This is an absolute must when thinking of Upper West Side eats.

Paquito’s Mexican Restaurant

Paquito’s is a hidden gem that offers a vibrant and authentic Mexican dining experience. The tacos are a must-try, bursting with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for a casual dinner with friends or a festive celebration.

A Modern American Palate

For those seeking contemporary American cuisine, the Upper West Side offers a range of restaurants that showcase innovative dishes and locally sourced ingredients.

Shake Shack

While technically a chain, the Shake Shack on Columbus Avenue holds a special place in the hearts of Upper West Siders. The combination of juicy burgers, crispy crinkle-cut fries, and creamy milkshakes is simply irresistible. It’s a quick, affordable, and satisfying option for a casual meal.

Westville

Westville is a true Upper West Side staple, known for its fresh, seasonal produce and creative vegetable-focused dishes. The market plate allows you to customize your meal with a variety of flavorful sides. The menu changes regularly to reflect the best of each season, making every visit a unique experience.

French Elegance and Charm

Indulge in the sophisticated flavors of French cuisine at these Upper West Side gems:

Cafe Luxembourg

Step into Cafe Luxembourg and be transported to a classic Parisian bistro. With its elegant decor, impeccable service, and refined menu, Cafe Luxembourg is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. The steak frites and the French onion soup are perennial favorites.

Brasserie Cognac East

Another excellent choice is Brasserie Cognac East. From steak frites to a carefully curated wine selection, this restaurant is a beautiful addition to the Upper West Side Eats.

Asian Delights

Explore the diverse flavors of Asia at these highly-rated Upper West Side restaurants:

Han Dynasty

If you’re craving authentic Sichuan cuisine, look no further than Han Dynasty. Their spicy dan dan noodles and mapo tofu are legendary. Be warned: the spice levels are no joke! Come prepared for a fiery culinary adventure.

Japanese Excellence

For sushi lovers, there are countless options on the Upper West Side. Sushi Yasaka is always a great option, or try Kissaki UWS for more upscale fare.

The Perfect Brunch Spots

No Upper West Side culinary journey is complete without experiencing its vibrant brunch scene. These are a few of the go-to brunch restaurants:

Sarabeth’s

Sarabeth’s is a brunch institution, known for its fluffy lemon ricotta pancakes, creamy eggs benedict, and homemade jams. Be prepared for a wait, especially on weekends, but the delicious food is well worth it.

Good Enough to Eat

Good Enough to Eat is another local favorite, serving up hearty portions of classic American breakfast and brunch fare. The buttermilk pancakes and omelets are always a hit. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it feel like you’re dining in someone’s home. This is a quintessential Upper West Side eats experience.

Other Notable Mentions

The Upper West Side’s culinary scene is far too vast to cover in just a few categories. Here are some other restaurants that deserve recognition:

Zabar’s Cafe

While technically a grocery store with a cafe, Zabar’s is an Upper West Side icon. Grab a smoked salmon bagel, a cup of coffee, and soak in the bustling atmosphere. It’s a quintessential New York experience.

Gray’s Papaya

For a quick and cheap bite, head to Gray’s Papaya for their famous hot dogs and tropical drinks. It’s a classic New York City institution.

Levain Bakery

Okay, not a restaurant, but essential when discussing Upper West Side food. Levain’s massive, gooey chocolate chip cookies are legendary. A must-try for any visitor to the neighborhood.

The Smith

While technically with several locations, this is a restaurant to consider. The Smith on the Upper West Side has a number of delicious items and a great brunch.

Bar Boulud

Bar Boulud offers a comfortable setting with French-inspired bistro favorites. The ambiance is casual yet sophisticated, perfect for a casual meal or a more upscale occasion. The menu features a variety of dishes made with fresh, seasonal ingredients.

Amsterdam Burger Co.

Amsterdam Burger Co. serves up delicious burgers in a modern, and friendly atmosphere. All items are cooked to perfection, and with a number of choices to choose from, you can customize your meal perfectly.

Ocean Grill

For those craving fresh seafood, Ocean Grill is the place to go. The restaurant offers a wide selection of seafood dishes, all prepared with the freshest ingredients. The raw bar is a highlight, and the atmosphere is elegant and sophisticated.

P.J. Clarke’s Lincoln Square

P.J. Clarke’s Lincoln Square is a historic tavern known for its classic American fare and lively atmosphere. The burgers are a standout, and the beer selection is impressive. It’s a great spot to grab a drink and a bite to eat after a show at Lincoln Center.

Rosa Mexicano

Rosa Mexicano is a vibrant restaurant known for its modern take on Mexican cuisine. The guacamole is prepared tableside, and the margaritas are a must-try. The atmosphere is festive and colorful, perfect for a celebration.

Tavern on the Green

Tavern on the Green is a legendary Central Park institution, offering a refined dining experience in a stunning setting. The menu features classic American dishes with a modern twist. It’s a great spot for a special occasion or a romantic dinner.

Maison Pickle

Maison Pickle is a beloved comfort food spot with Southern influences. The restaurant boasts an excellent menu of cocktails, appetizers and entrees, all made to impress.

Celeste

Celeste offers fresh and homemade Italian pasta, and fresh seafood. The restaurant is casual and cozy, offering diners a feeling of home while in New York City.

Momofuku Noodle Bar

Momofuku Noodle Bar features a range of noodles, dumplings, and meat dishes, as well as a beverage menu with sake, beer, wine, and cocktails. With an affordable price point and excellent food, it is hard to go wrong.

Fumo

Fumo is known for its brick oven pizza and high-quality Italian classics. Located near Columbia University, this is an excellent option for Columbia students or those looking to dine near Morningside Heights.

Conclusion

The Upper West Side’s food scene is a vibrant reflection of the neighborhood’s diverse character. From classic Italian eateries to trendy American bistros and exotic Asian restaurants, there’s something to satisfy every palate. This list of twenty-five favorite restaurants is just a starting point. We encourage you to explore the Upper West Side’s culinary landscape and discover your own hidden gems. So, venture out, try something new, and savor the flavors of the Upper West Side. What are some of your favorites when it comes to Upper West Side eats? Let us know your picks!