The Twenty-Four Most Fabulous Restaurants in Staten Island, New York
Introduction
Staten Island. Often overlooked, sometimes misunderstood, but always surprisingly delightful, especially when it comes to its culinary scene. Forget the stereotypes; this borough is a hidden treasure trove of gastronomic delights, a place where authentic flavors meet modern innovation. From cozy neighborhood trattorias to upscale dining destinations, Staten Island boasts a diverse array of restaurants that deserve a spotlight. Prepare to be amazed as we unveil twenty-four of the most fabulous restaurants, each offering a unique and unforgettable dining experience. This isn’t just a list; it’s a curated journey through the very best of Staten Island’s food scene. We’ve selected these establishments based on a careful blend of ambiance, exceptional food quality, outstanding service, unique culinary experiences, and overall value. So, ditch the usual suspects and prepare to discover the hidden gems of Staten Island.
Fine Dining & Special Occasions
The Stone House
A beacon of elegance, The Stone House stands as a testament to refined dining. Housed in a beautifully restored historic building, this restaurant offers a sophisticated atmosphere perfect for special occasions. The menu features contemporary American cuisine with a focus on seasonal ingredients. Picture yourself savoring pan-seared scallops with truffle risotto or indulging in a perfectly cooked steak. The atmosphere is undeniably romantic and upscale, making it ideal for celebrating anniversaries or milestones. Be sure to try the signature lobster bisque. The price range is higher end, but the experience is worth every penny. Located on Richmond Terrace, you can visit their website for reservations or call them directly. Its commitment to excellence makes The Stone House a true gem.
Angelina’s Ristorante
Boasting stunning views of the Outerbridge Crossing, Angelina’s is more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. Its elegant dining room, impeccable service, and expertly crafted Italian dishes make it a destination for celebrations. Start with the creamy burrata appetizer and move on to the homemade pasta, the seafood is always fresh and expertly prepared. The restaurant exudes an air of sophistication, and it is recommended you dress to impress. Expect a higher price point, reflecting the quality of the ingredients and the service. Nestled on Page Avenue, reservations are highly recommended. Many consider this place to be a staple of the Staten Island fine dining landscape.
Ruddy & Dean
For a classic steakhouse experience with a modern twist, look no further than Ruddy & Dean. This upscale restaurant boasts a lively atmosphere, top-notch service, and, of course, expertly grilled steaks. Their dry-aged ribeye is a must-try, as is the creamy mac and cheese. The ambiance is sophisticated yet comfortable, making it perfect for a special night out or a business dinner. Expect a higher price range, in line with the quality of the ingredients and the overall experience. Find it on Arthur Kill Road. Calling ahead for reservations is a great way to secure a spot at this local favorite.
Authentic Italian Flavors
Casa Nuova
Step into Casa Nuova, and you’ll be transported to a traditional Italian trattoria. This family-run restaurant serves up authentic dishes made with love and the freshest ingredients. The homemade pasta is a must-try, and the seafood specials are always a hit. Don’t miss the classic spaghetti carbonara. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it perfect for a casual meal with friends or family. The price is moderate, offering excellent value for the quality. Found on Hylan Boulevard, Casa Nuova is a true neighborhood gem.
Nino’s Restaurant
A Staten Island institution, Nino’s Restaurant has been serving up classic Italian dishes for decades. This family-owned establishment is known for its generous portions, friendly service, and traditional recipes. From the perfectly al dente pasta to the flavorful sauces, everything is made with love. The baked clams are a signature dish, and the osso buco is always a crowd-pleaser. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a comforting meal. Its accessible pricing makes it a great option for everyone. Located on Amboy Road, it’s a must-try for any Italian food lover.
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern
While technically a pizzeria, Denino’s deserves a spot in this category for its dedication to authentic Italian flavors. Their thin-crust pizzas are legendary, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. But don’t stop at pizza; their pasta dishes and seafood are also excellent. You simply can’t go wrong with the margherita pie. The atmosphere is casual and lively, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a family gathering. The pricing is moderate. Found on Port Richmond Avenue, Denino’s is a Staten Island staple. It is one of the most well-known spots on the island.
Lorenzo’s Restaurant, Bar & Cabaret
More than just a restaurant, Lorenzo’s provides a complete evening of entertainment. While it does have a cabaret, the Italian food is authentic and tasty. Enjoy the chicken parmigiana or the lasagna. They also serve brunch, so you can start your day with them or end it with a show. Found on Richmond Avenue, this restaurant and cabaret is a destination.
Casual Eats & Family Favorites
Ho’ Brah Taco Joint
Sometimes you just need tacos! Thankfully, Ho’ Brah Taco Joint can deliver the goods. They have an interesting menu of both tradition and non-traditional tacos. Enjoy the surf and turf or the more standard carne asada. The restaurant is moderately priced, making it a nice spot to bring the entire family. Found on Forest Avenue, it’s sure to become a family favorite.
Bayou
Transport yourself to the heart of Louisiana with a visit to Bayou. This restaurant serves up authentic Cajun and Creole cuisine in a lively and festive atmosphere. From jambalaya to gumbo to crawfish etouffee, you’ll find all your favorite Southern dishes here. The etouffee is a fan favorite. The atmosphere is casual and fun, and the prices are moderate. Located on Bay Street, Bayou is a taste of the South in Staten Island.
Lee Simms Family Restaurant
Lee Simms Family Restaurant has been serving up delicious and affordable diner fare. This local institution is known for its friendly service, generous portions, and classic dishes. Enjoy the burgers, sandwiches, and breakfast anytime menu. Everything is incredibly affordable and well prepared. It’s a local institution.
Brothers Restaurant
Classic comfort food with a smile! Brothers Restaurant serves up all-American favorites like burgers, fries, and milkshakes. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, and the prices are affordable. Found on Victory Boulevard, Brothers is a great spot for a quick and satisfying meal. Be sure to check out their milkshake menu for an extra special treat.
Ralph’s Famous Italian Ices
While not a traditional restaurant, Ralph’s is a must-visit Staten Island destination. This local institution has been serving up delicious Italian ices for decades. Cool off with a classic lemon ice or try one of their more unique flavors. It is extremely affordable. With multiple locations throughout Staten Island, Ralph’s is the perfect spot for a sweet treat on a hot day.
Global Flavors
Lakruwana
Embark on a culinary journey to Sri Lanka with a visit to Lakruwana. This restaurant serves up authentic Sri Lankan cuisine in a vibrant and colorful setting. From the spicy curries to the flavorful hoppers, everything is bursting with flavor. Start with the kottu roti and move on to the seafood curry. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, and the prices are moderate. Located on Bay Street, Lakruwana is a true hidden gem.
Taste of Shanghai
Experience the authentic flavors of Shanghai. The restaurant is moderately priced, making it a nice spot to bring the entire family. Found on Hylan Boulevard, it’s sure to become a favorite.
Beseda Restaurant
Step into Beseda and you’ll be transported to Russia. The authentic Russian cuisine is unlike anything else on the island. Start with the Chicken Kiev and then move on to the borscht. The atmosphere is comfortable and the service is friendly. Found on Castle Avenue, this restaurant is sure to become a place you frequent.
Pancho Villa’s Mexican Restaurant
Looking for some great Mexican food? Pancho Villa’s has you covered. From burritos, to tacos, to enchiladas, the options are limitless! Start with the nachos and then get some enchiladas. The atmosphere is comfortable and the service is friendly. Found on Forest Avenue, it’s sure to become a family favorite.
Waterfront Dining & Views
The Veranda
Overlooking the Great Kills Harbor, The Veranda offers breathtaking views and delicious seafood. This restaurant is perfect for a romantic dinner or a special occasion. Enjoy the fresh oysters and the grilled swordfish while taking in the stunning sunset. The atmosphere is elegant and romantic, and the price range is moderate to high. Nestled in Great Kills, The Veranda is a true gem of Staten Island.
South Fin Grill
Located on the boardwalk, South Fin Grill offers stunning views of the ocean and the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge. This restaurant serves up fresh seafood and American cuisine in a relaxed and casual atmosphere. Enjoy the lobster rolls and the fish tacos while soaking up the sun. The atmosphere is lively and fun, and the prices are moderate. Situated in South Beach, South Fin Grill is a perfect spot for a summer day.
Pizza Perfection
Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria
For a taste of authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria. This family-owned establishment has been serving up thin-crust pizzas for decades. The crust is crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are always fresh. The atmosphere is casual and lively, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite. Joe & Pat’s is extremely affordable. Located on Victory Boulevard, Joe & Pat’s is a must-try for any pizza lover.
Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza
Goodfellas offers brick oven pizza with fresh ingredients. This Staten Island favorite is known for using high-quality ingredients, producing pizzas with a delicious, slightly smoky flavor. The ambiance is warm and inviting, and its mid-range pricing makes it a great option for a casual meal. Located on Hylan Boulevard, Goodfellas is a true pizza institution.
Brunch Hotspots
Beso
Beso offers a unique brunch experience with Latin-inspired dishes. Indulge in their creative menu, featuring items like churro waffles and avocado toast with a Latin twist. The atmosphere is lively and trendy, with a beautiful outdoor patio. Its mid-range pricing makes it a great spot for a weekend brunch with friends. You can find them on Bay Street. Be sure to try the brunch cocktails!
Beans and Leaves Cafe
While they serve coffee, they also have some amazing breakfast options. Beans and Leaves Cafe serves breakfast and lunch all day long. The atmosphere is very casual, the pricing is affordable, and the service is friendly. You can find them on Hylan Boulevard.
The Kettle Black
For a taste of classic American brunch with a modern twist, head to The Kettle Black. This restaurant offers a menu filled with familiar favorites, like pancakes, omelets, and eggs benedict, all prepared with a focus on quality ingredients. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the prices are moderate. Located on Bay Street, The Kettle Black is a perfect spot for a leisurely weekend brunch.
Tips for Dining on Staten Island
Getting around Staten Island is easiest by car, although public transportation options are available. The Staten Island Ferry provides a free connection to Manhattan, making it a convenient way to access the borough’s dining scene. Reservations are highly recommended, especially for fine dining restaurants and during peak hours. Parking can be challenging in some areas, so be sure to factor that into your plans. Keep an eye out for seasonal menus and outdoor seating options, which can enhance your dining experience.
Conclusion
The culinary landscape of Staten Island is as diverse and vibrant as the borough itself. From authentic Italian trattorias to innovative global cuisines, there’s something for every palate. The twenty-four restaurants highlighted in this article represent the very best of Staten Island’s food scene, offering a blend of exceptional food, inviting ambiance, and outstanding service. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, we encourage you to explore these fabulous restaurants and discover your own hidden gems. So, grab your appetite and embark on a culinary adventure – you won’t be disappointed! The delicious offerings will leave you wanting more.
