The 27 Most Popular Bars in the East Village, New York City

East Village Watering Holes: A Curated Selection

From dimly lit dives where history whispers from every corner to sleek cocktail lounges serving up innovative concoctions, the East Village pulsates with a nightlife energy unlike any other neighborhood in New York City. This legendary enclave, once a haven for artists, rebels, and immigrants, continues to evolve while stubbornly clinging to its fiercely independent spirit. The East Village bar scene is a testament to that spirit, offering a kaleidoscope of experiences to suit every mood and palate.

The East Village, a vibrant tapestry of culture and history, is renowned for its eclectic mix of restaurants, shops, and, of course, bars. Nestled between the Lower East Side and Gramercy Park, this neighborhood exudes a unique charm that attracts a diverse crowd, from students and artists to seasoned New Yorkers and curious tourists. Its bar scene is a reflection of its character – gritty, authentic, and always surprising. But with so many options available, navigating this liquid landscape can be a daunting task.

That’s where this list comes in. Based on a combination of local recommendations, critical acclaim, consistently high ratings, and sheer popularity, we’ve curated a guide to the very best bars the East Village has to offer. We’ve taken into account different tastes and preferences, ensuring there’s something for everyone, from the casual beer drinker to the discerning cocktail aficionado.

Prepare to embark on a journey through the heart of the East Village’s nightlife. We’ll explore a selection of bars with something for everyone, making this your perfect guide to navigate the exhilarating and diverse East Village bar scene. Let’s dive in and discover what makes these spots the most popular watering holes in one of New York City’s most iconic neighborhoods.

McSorley’s Old Ale House

A true New York City institution, McSorley’s is the oldest Irish pub in the city, instantly recognizable by its sawdust-covered floors and the simple, timeless menu.

McSorley’s earns its popularity through its unwavering dedication to tradition and its authentic, no-frills atmosphere. Stepping inside is like stepping back in time, offering a glimpse into the city’s rich history. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking an unpretentious and genuinely old-school experience.

They serve only two types of ale: light and dark, ordered in pairs. Don’t expect anything fancy; simplicity is key here.

Located at 15 E 7th St, near the Astor Place subway stop, McSorley’s is easily accessible.

Expect to spend around $ for a couple of beers.

Tip: Don’t bother asking for a menu. Just order “two ales,” and let the tradition speak for itself.

Death & Company

A pioneer in the craft cocktail movement, Death & Company is known for its serious dedication to the art of mixology and its intimate, speakeasy-style ambiance.

Its popularity stems from its consistently innovative and expertly crafted cocktails, along with its sophisticated and discreet atmosphere. It’s a destination for those seeking a truly elevated drinking experience.

One of their signature drinks might be a carefully balanced concoction featuring rare spirits and house-made bitters. The menu is constantly evolving, reflecting the bartenders’ creativity and passion.

Find it at 433 E 6th St, a short walk from the First Avenue L train station.

Be prepared to spend $$$ for their exquisite cocktails.

Local Secret: Arrive early, as it fills up quickly, and be prepared to wait. The wait is worth it.

Please Don’t Tell (PDT)

Another iconic speakeasy, Please Don’t Tell is hidden behind a phone booth inside Crif Dogs, offering a unique and playful entry point.

PDT’s popularity rests on its exclusivity, its inventive cocktails, and its whimsical atmosphere. The combination of a hidden entrance and expertly made drinks creates a memorable and sought-after experience.

Their signature drink might be a bacon-infused bourbon cocktail or another equally inventive and delicious creation.

Enter through the phone booth at 113 St Marks Pl, accessible via the Astor Place subway station.

The price range is $$$ for their creative and potent drinks.

Tip: Reservations are highly recommended and can be made online.

Double Wide

A honky-tonk haven, Double Wide brings a taste of the South to the East Village, complete with vintage décor, cheap beer, and a rowdy atmosphere.

Its popularity is driven by its unpretentious vibe, its affordable drinks, and its embrace of a distinctly Southern aesthetic. It’s a place to let loose and have a good time without breaking the bank.

Try a Lone Star beer or a shot of whiskey. The drinks are simple and the prices are right.

Located at 505 E 12th St, it’s accessible from the First Avenue L train.

Expect to spend $ for a fun, unpretentious night out.

Tip: Check out their themed nights for even more Southern charm.

Boilermaker

A lively spot inspired by classic American bars, Boilermaker offers a wide selection of craft beers, cocktails, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Its appeal lies in its combination of quality drinks, friendly service, and a comfortable setting. It’s a great place to relax and enjoy a drink with friends.

Try their signature Boilermaker – a shot of whiskey paired with a beer. They also have a great selection of rotating craft beers on tap.

Find it at 13 First Ave, easily accessible from the Second Avenue F train.

The price range is $$ for a solid selection of drinks and a good time.

Local Secret: Their happy hour deals are some of the best in the neighborhood.

Doc Holliday’s

A classic dive bar with a loyal following, Doc Holliday’s is known for its no-nonsense atmosphere, cheap drinks, and late-night crowd.

Its enduring popularity is due to its affordability, its unpretentious vibe, and its welcoming attitude. It’s a place where everyone feels comfortable.

Grab a cheap beer or a well drink. Simplicity is key here.

Located at 141 Avenue A, it’s a short walk from the First Avenue L train.

The price range is $ for the budget-conscious drinker.

Tip: Be prepared for a lively and sometimes rowdy atmosphere, especially late at night.

The Wayland

A charming cocktail bar with a focus on fresh ingredients and farm-to-table practices.

Its draw is its commitment to quality ingredients and its expertly crafted cocktails, as well as its cozy and inviting atmosphere.

Their signature cocktails feature seasonal fruits and vegetables, showcasing their dedication to fresh and local ingredients.

Find it at 700 E 9th St, a short walk from the First Avenue L train.

Expect to spend $$ for high-quality drinks in a comfortable setting.

Local Secret: They often have live music, adding to the bar’s already vibrant atmosphere.

Otto’s Shrunken Head

A tiki bar with a delightfully kitschy atmosphere, Otto’s Shrunken Head serves up tropical cocktails in a fun and festive setting.

Its popularity stems from its unique theme, its potent cocktails, and its playful vibe. It’s a great place to escape the city and enjoy a taste of the tropics.

Try a classic tiki cocktail like a Mai Tai or a Zombie. They are strong and delicious.

Located at 538 E 14th St, easily accessible from the First Avenue L train.

The price range is $$ for their fun and fruity cocktails.

Tip: Check out their events calendar for live music and other special events.

Sophie’s

A local favorite known for its strong drinks, friendly bartenders, and no-frills atmosphere.

Sophie’s is popular because of its affordability, its unpretentious vibe, and its sense of community. It’s a place where regulars feel at home.

Order a well drink or a cheap beer. The prices are hard to beat.

Find it at 509 E 5th St, a short walk from the Second Avenue F train.

The price range is $ for those on a tight budget.

Tip: Be prepared for a cash-only bar.

Mace

This cocktail bar focuses on global flavors, offering a diverse menu inspired by spices from around the world.

Mace’s allure is its innovative cocktail menu, its sophisticated ambiance, and its commitment to using unique and interesting ingredients.

Each cocktail is named after a spice and incorporates its flavor profile in a creative way.

It’s located at 35 W 8th Street and accessible via the subway.

The price range is $$$ because they offer an elevated cocktail experience

The Wren

An gastropub offering a cozy spot and craft beer selection

The Wren is popular because of its neighborhood feel, it’s extensive drinks, and the warm atmosphere

A nice selection of craft beers or a fancy cocktails are the go to drinks

They are located on Bowery and the prices range is around $$

Niagara

A bar that plays music and is one of the last vestiges of old East Village

It’s popular because of its history, diverse crowd, and loud music

You can drink anything here and the prices range around $

Josie’s East

Offers cocktails in a relaxed environment, perfect for chatting

A neighborhood joint with craft beer and mixed drinks is the popularity of Josie’s

It’s located on Avenue A, the prices are around $$

Crocodile Lounge

Offers free pizza during happy hour and makes it a neighborhood favorite

Cheap beers and a welcoming crowd is what makes this place special

You can drink beer and the prices are relatively around $

Boulton and Watt

A place that offers food and good drinks

The restaurant/bar is popular because the food is great and the environment is also great.

A cocktail is always a good choice and the prices are around $$

The Blind Barber

A speakeasy located behind a barbershop offering great drinks.

It’s a speakeasy making it popular because it’s hidden and the drinks are also great.

A cocktail will set you back a $$

Eve

A wine bar with a focus on natural wines

Eve’s popularity stems from its unique wines and the knowledgable staff.

It offers an elevated cocktail experience so it’s around $$$

Amor y Amargo

A bitters tasting room that focuses on cocktails

Its popularity is derived from tasting amazing cocktails.

It is a luxury experience with $$$ pricing.

The 13th Step

College bar that’s popular because of the drinks.

Offers college nights out which makes it popular

The usual college drinks are around $

Subject

Offers dance music from DJs and a good time

It is popular for the music that’s played.

The drinks are $$

Offside Tavern

A soccer bar that draws a soccer crowd

It is popular because it offers a sport that’s not often found.

Cheap beer is a good bet and is around $

Holiday Cocktail Lounge

A dive bar where you can just chill

It’s popular because it’s an old school East Village bar.

Cheap beer and well drinks will be $

Alphaville

A live venue where bands play music

Its popularity is due to the different bands playing.

Beer and a shot will be $

Ace Bar

Pool tables and a neighborhood feel.

Popular because it’s a neighborhood bar.

Cheap beers are $

Rosemary’s East

An Italian restaurant that is also a bar

It’s a popular place for foodies to eat at.

Wine is around $$

Goodnight Sonny

A cozy bar that has a vintage feel

It is popular due to the friendly environment

Cocktails are around $$

The VNYL

A place that is a bar and restaurant

It has become popular because it’s a great place to hang out.

The cocktails will cost you $$$

Common Threads & Themes

The East Village bar scene is experiencing a fascinating blend of trends. While the classic dive bar remains a beloved institution, there’s a growing emphasis on craft cocktails and unique drinking experiences. Many bars are focusing on using fresh, local ingredients and incorporating innovative techniques into their drink-making. We also see a resurgence of classic cocktails, with bartenders putting their own spin on old favorites. In addition, local breweries are having their moment with a lot of bars focusing on local talent.

What truly sets the East Village bar scene apart is its unique blend of history, affordability, and alternative vibe. It’s a place where you can find everything from a century-old Irish pub to a cutting-edge cocktail lounge. The affordability of many bars makes it accessible to a wide range of people, while the neighborhood’s artistic spirit fosters a sense of creativity and experimentation.

Conclusion

The East Village offers an unparalleled variety of bars, catering to every taste and preference. From historic dives to innovative cocktail lounges, this neighborhood provides a unique and vibrant nightlife experience.

We encourage you to explore the bars on this list, discover your own favorites, and support these local establishments. The East Village bar scene is a vital part of the neighborhood’s character, and your patronage helps to keep it thriving.

So grab a friend, raise a glass, and experience the electric energy of the East Village bar scene. You’re sure to find a place that you’ll call home, if only for a night.