Must-Visit Bars in Staten Island: Your Ultimate Guide to NYC’s Best-Kept Secrets

Forget the stereotypes; Staten Island’s nightlife is a vibrant tapestry woven with cozy pubs, lively sports bars, and trendy cocktail lounges. Often overlooked in favor of its flashier Manhattan neighbor or its trendy Brooklyn counterpart, Staten Island offers a uniquely authentic and surprisingly diverse bar scene just waiting to be explored. This often forgotten borough boasts a range of watering holes, from historic establishments serving generations of locals to newcomers pushing the boundaries of mixology.

Staten Island offers a unique blend of small-town charm and big-city energy. The borough’s bar scene reflects this dynamic, providing options to cater to every taste and occasion. Whether you are seeking a perfectly poured pint, a handcrafted cocktail, a place to cheer on your favorite team, or simply a friendly spot to unwind after a long day, Staten Island delivers.

This curated guide to the most beloved bars in Staten Island offers something for everyone. So, get ready to discover the hidden gems and local favorites that make Staten Island’s nightlife scene a true treasure. Prepare to be surprised, delighted, and perhaps even find your new go-to spot. This exploration of Staten Island’s bar scene proves that the forgotten borough has a lot to offer, and it’s time you discovered it.

Categories of Bars

To make your Staten Island bar adventure easier to navigate, we have divided the featured establishments into helpful categories. This allows you to quickly identify bars that match your mood and preferences.

Classic Irish Pubs: A Staten Island Staple

The rich Irish heritage of Staten Island is reflected in its abundance of authentic Irish pubs. These establishments are more than just places to grab a drink; they are community hubs where stories are shared, friendships are forged, and traditions are celebrated. Expect warm welcomes, hearty food, live music, and of course, perfectly poured pints of Guinness.

Sports Bars: Where the Action Happens

For sports enthusiasts, Staten Island offers a variety of lively sports bars where you can catch the big game, cheer on your favorite team, and enjoy a spirited atmosphere. These bars feature numerous screens, comfortable seating, game-day specials, and an energetic crowd, making them the perfect place to watch any sporting event.

Waterfront Bars: Drinks with a View

Enjoy stunning views of the New York Harbor and the Manhattan skyline while sipping your favorite beverage at one of Staten Island’s waterfront bars. These establishments offer a unique and picturesque setting, whether you are looking for a romantic evening or a casual gathering with friends. The combination of breathtaking scenery and refreshing drinks creates an unforgettable experience.

Craft Beer Havens: A Brewer’s Paradise

Craft beer lovers will rejoice in Staten Island’s growing craft beer scene. From local breweries to bars with extensive beer selections, you will find a wide variety of unique and flavorful brews to sample. Explore different styles, discover new favorites, and appreciate the artistry and craftsmanship behind each pint.

Cocktail Lounges: Where Mixology Meets Ambiance

For those seeking a sophisticated and stylish experience, Staten Island’s cocktail lounges offer expertly crafted cocktails in an elegant setting. Talented mixologists create innovative and classic drinks using high-quality ingredients and techniques. The ambiance is often intimate and upscale, making these lounges perfect for a special occasion or a night out with friends.

Dive Bars: Keeping It Real

If you are looking for a no-frills, laid-back atmosphere, Staten Island’s dive bars are the perfect choice. These establishments offer affordable drinks, friendly regulars, and a comfortable, unpretentious vibe. They are the kind of places where you can relax, be yourself, and enjoy a genuine local experience.

Live Music Venues: Tune In & Turn Up

From rock to blues to acoustic sets, Staten Island offers a range of live music venues where you can enjoy talented local musicians and bands. These venues provide a vibrant and energetic atmosphere, perfect for a night of entertainment and dancing.

Restaurants with Great Bars: Eat, Drink, and Be Merry

Sometimes you want a great meal to go with your drinks. Staten Island has plenty of restaurants where the bar is as much of a draw as the food. Enjoy a delicious dinner and then settle in for a few drinks at a lively bar, all in the same location.

The Most Beloved Bars

Here are some of the most popular bars in Staten Island, divided by category:

Classic Irish Pubs

The Irish Pub (Name Changed): Located in New Dorp, this pub is a Staten Island institution known for its friendly atmosphere and live Irish music sessions. Why it’s a favorite: It’s the best place to experience authentic Irish culture. Recommendation: Try a pint of Guinness or a classic Irish whiskey.

Flanagan’s On The Bowery (Name Changed): A cozy pub on Forest Avenue offering traditional Irish fare and a wide selection of beers. Why it’s a favorite: It’s a great place to catch up with friends and enjoy a hearty meal. Recommendation: Order the shepherd’s pie.

Sports Bars

MVP Bar & Grill (Name Changed): A Staten Island sports bar with a lively atmosphere, numerous TVs, and a full menu of American classics. Why it’s a favorite: It’s the perfect place to watch any sporting event with friends. Recommendation: Try the chicken wings and a cold beer.

The Dugout (Name Changed): A popular sports bar in Westerleigh known for its friendly service and great happy hour specials. Why it’s a favorite: It’s a great spot for affordable drinks and a relaxed atmosphere. Recommendation: Check out their daily drink specials.

Waterfront Bars

Above Rooftop (Name Changed): Overlooking the iconic St. George Ferry Terminal and the Manhattan Skyline, this bar offers stunning panoramic views. Why it’s a favorite: The view is unlike any other on Staten Island. Recommendation: Enjoy a refreshing cocktail while watching the sunset.

The Deck at Richmond County Yacht Club (Name Changed): A seasonal waterfront bar offering casual dining and drinks with beautiful views of Great Kills Harbor. Why it’s a favorite: A great place to unwind on a summer evening. Recommendation: Try their seafood dishes and a cold beer.

Craft Beer Havens

Flagship Brewing Company (Name Changed): A local brewery producing a variety of craft beers in a spacious taproom. Why it’s a favorite: Staten Island’s first and most prolific brewery, always pouring fresh pints. Recommendation: Try the Kill Van Kull Cream Ale.

Kills Boro Brewing Company (Name Changed): Another local brewery with a focus on unique and innovative beer styles. Why it’s a favorite: A local favorite for its experimental brews and friendly atmosphere. Recommendation: Try their rotating seasonal IPAs.

Bessemer (Name Changed): An eclectic cocktail bar and cafe offering a thoughtfully curated beer selection that features local brews. Why it’s a favorite: An awesome place to enjoy creative cocktails and unique beer options in a cool atmosphere. Recommendation: Ask for their recommended cocktail or craft beer.

Cocktail Lounges

The Coupe (Name Changed): A sophisticated cocktail lounge offering expertly crafted drinks in an intimate setting. Why it’s a favorite: Staten Island’s go-to place to experience elegant cocktails and a upscale ambiance. Recommendation: Try their signature Old Fashioned.

The Gilded Grape (Name Changed): This establishment offers great cocktails and an even better wine selection. Why it’s a favorite: A perfect spot for a date night or after-dinner drinks. Recommendation: Ask for their recommendations based on your tastes.

Dive Bars

The Kettle Black (Name Changed): A classic dive bar with a loyal following, known for its cheap drinks and unpretentious atmosphere. Why it’s a favorite: Staten Island’s a classic, divey spot to kick back with friends. Recommendation: Order a shot and a beer.

Ralph’s Tavern (Name Changed): A neighborhood institution with a long history, offering affordable drinks and a friendly crowd. Why it’s a favorite: A perfect spot to relax and enjoy a cheap beer and some time off. Recommendation: Try one of their unique, locally sourced beers.

Live Music Venues

The Full Cup (Name Changed): The Full Cup has been a part of the community for years. Locals love to come here for great music in a low-key atmosphere. Why it’s a favorite: It is a great spot to check out local artists and discover great music. Recommendation: Arrive early to grab a good spot and a cold beer.

Clancy’s Tavern (Name Changed): Known as a classic Irish pub, Clancy’s Tavern also brings in some of the best local music acts on Staten Island. Why it’s a favorite: Enjoy a classic pub atmosphere with some of the best musical acts on the island. Recommendation: Check ahead to see who is playing, and try a classic Irish whiskey.

Restaurants with Great Bars

Angelina’s Ristorante (Name Changed): A popular Italian restaurant with a lively bar scene, offering a wide selection of wines and cocktails. Why it’s a favorite: Enjoy a delicious meal and then settle in for drinks at the bar. Recommendation: Try their house-made pasta and a glass of wine.

Ruddy & Dean (Name Changed): A great eatery with a lively bar scene offering specialty drinks, wine, and beer, located right off the water. Why it’s a favorite: Ruddy and Dean combines great eats with a happening bar scene. Recommendation: Stop in after work and enjoy a cocktail and some great appetizers.

There are so many more amazing bars that contribute to Staten Island’s nightlife. From The Burrito Bar (Name Changed), to Ho Brah (Name Changed), and even Jody’s Club Forest (Name Changed), one is sure to find a bar that they love when visiting Staten Island.

A Taste of Staten Island

The beauty of Staten Island’s bar scene lies in its authenticity. Unlike the trend-driven establishments in other boroughs, Staten Island’s bars offer a genuine, community-focused experience. Here, you will find friendly faces, unpretentious atmospheres, and a sense of belonging. This is where locals gather, stories are shared, and memories are made. The borough’s unique character is reflected in its bars, offering a refreshing alternative to the often-overcrowded and overpriced establishments in other parts of the city.

Tips for Exploring the Bar Scene

Navigating Staten Island’s bar scene is relatively easy, but here are some helpful tips to enhance your experience:

Transportation: While Staten Island is accessible by public transportation, including the iconic Staten Island Ferry, ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are often the most convenient way to get around, especially at night.

Safety: As with any nightlife scene, it’s important to drink responsibly and be aware of your surroundings. Travel in groups, look out for your friends, and avoid walking alone late at night.

Happy Hour Deals: Take advantage of the many happy hour specials offered at bars throughout Staten Island. This is a great way to sample different drinks and save money.

Conclusion

Staten Island’s bar scene is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. With its diverse range of establishments, from classic Irish pubs to trendy cocktail lounges, there is something for everyone. So, what are you waiting for? Grab some friends and explore the vibrant bar scene of Staten Island. You might just discover your new favorite spot. Enjoy responsible drinking and prepare for a delightful surprise.