Fourteen of the Best Non Touristy Things to Do in New York City

Introduction

Imagine stepping away from the flashing lights of Times Square, trading in the long lines at the Statue of Liberty, and instead finding yourself immersed in the authentic rhythm of New York City. This isn’t about ticking off the usual tourist traps; it’s about discovering the hidden gems, the local haunts, and the experiences that truly capture the spirit of this incredible metropolis. While the iconic landmarks are undoubtedly impressive, the real magic of New York City lies in its diverse neighborhoods, its vibrant cultural scene, and the everyday moments that define its unique character.

If you’re yearning for a more genuine and enriching travel experience, you’re in the right place. This article unveils fourteen unique and authentic experiences that will allow you to explore New York City like a local. Stepping off the beaten path means fewer crowds, deeper cultural immersion, and the chance to uncover the city’s best-kept secrets. Get ready to ditch the tourist guides and embrace the real New York.

Exploring Hidden Neighborhoods

Discover the Charms of Red Hook

Nestled along the waterfront in Brooklyn, Red Hook offers a refreshing escape from the city’s relentless energy. This historically industrial neighborhood boasts stunning views of the Statue of Liberty and the Manhattan skyline, all while maintaining a laid-back and slightly gritty charm. Take a stroll along the waterfront, where you can admire the maritime heritage and enjoy the salty breeze.

For a truly local experience, head to one of Red Hook’s renowned distilleries or breweries. Many offer tours and tastings, giving you a behind-the-scenes look at the craft production process. Explore the quirky shops and art galleries that line the streets, showcasing the neighborhood’s creative spirit. You will not find massive tour buses here, but you will find an authentic experience. The isolated nature of this neighborhood means it is usually not on a tourist’s itinerary.

Culinary Adventures Off the Beaten Path

Indulge in Authentic Flavors at Arthur Avenue

Venture into the Bronx and discover Arthur Avenue, New York City’s “real Little Italy.” Unlike the more tourist-centric Little Italy in Manhattan, Arthur Avenue retains its authentic charm and culinary traditions. This vibrant neighborhood is a feast for the senses, with its bustling markets, family-run restaurants, and tantalizing aromas wafting through the air.

Sample handmade pasta, artisanal cheeses, and freshly baked bread from local vendors. Indulge in a classic Italian meal at one of the many trattorias, where you’ll be treated like family. Don’t forget to grab a cannoli or a scoop of gelato for a sweet ending. Arthur Avenue is a hidden culinary gem that offers a genuine taste of Italy in the heart of New York City, and tourists rarely find this hidden gem. This is a great way to experience non touristy things to do in New York City.

Parks and Green Spaces Beyond Central Park

Escape the City Hustle at Wave Hill

While Central Park is undoubtedly iconic, there are numerous other parks and green spaces in New York City that offer a more tranquil and intimate experience. Wave Hill, located in the Bronx, is a hidden oasis that combines stunning gardens, breathtaking views of the Hudson River, and a peaceful atmosphere.

Explore the meticulously landscaped gardens, which showcase a variety of plant species from around the world. Take a leisurely stroll along the scenic paths, enjoy a picnic on the lawn, or attend one of the many cultural events and workshops offered throughout the year. Wave Hill is a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of the city, offering a serene environment to relax and reconnect with nature. Many tourists do not even know it exists.

Arts and Culture Beyond the Major Museums

Immerse Yourself in Art at The Bushwick Starr

Beyond the renowned museums like the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Museum of Modern Art, New York City boasts a thriving independent arts scene. The Bushwick Starr, located in Brooklyn, is a testament to this fact. This intimate theater venue showcases innovative and experimental performances, ranging from contemporary plays to dance and music.

The Bushwick Starr is known for its commitment to supporting emerging artists and pushing the boundaries of theatrical expression. Attending a performance here is a chance to experience cutting-edge art in a unique and intimate setting. This is where you will find true New Yorkers experiencing truly non touristy things to do in New York City. The shows are always excellent, and the theater itself is extremely small, meaning you always get a great seat.

Exploring Hidden Neighborhoods

Discover the Charms of Roosevelt Island

Roosevelt Island, once known for its hospitals and asylums, has transformed into a vibrant residential community with stunning views of Manhattan. Take the Roosevelt Island Tramway for a unique perspective of the city skyline. Explore the remnants of historic landmarks, such as the Smallpox Hospital, or simply enjoy a leisurely walk along the waterfront. This island has an eerie quality to it, but offers stunning views for a price much cheaper than other tourist attractions.

The island is generally quiet and filled with locals. It is also extremely safe and secure, and the tram is a great photo op. Most tourists only come here for the Four Freedoms Park, but the island has much more to offer than just that. This is a great way to experience non touristy things to do in New York City.

Culinary Adventures Off the Beaten Path

Indulge in Authentic Flavors at Jackson Heights

Venture to Jackson Heights, Queens, and discover one of the most diverse culinary scenes in New York City. This vibrant neighborhood is a melting pot of cultures, with a strong South Asian influence. Sample mouthwatering Indian, Bangladeshi, and Tibetan cuisine from the numerous restaurants and street vendors. Try spicy curries, savory dumplings, and aromatic teas. Jackson Heights is a culinary adventure that will tantalize your taste buds and expose you to a world of flavors.

Parks and Green Spaces Beyond Central Park

Escape the City Hustle at The Cloisters

Located in Upper Manhattan, The Cloisters is a branch of the Metropolitan Museum of Art dedicated to the art and architecture of medieval Europe. The museum is housed in a stunning complex of reconstructed medieval cloisters, creating a serene and contemplative atmosphere. Explore the beautiful gardens, admire the intricate tapestries, and immerse yourself in the art and history of the Middle Ages. The Cloisters is a hidden gem that offers a unique and peaceful escape from the urban landscape.

Arts and Culture Beyond the Major Museums

Immerse Yourself in Art at The Noguchi Museum

Located in Long Island City, Queens, The Noguchi Museum showcases the work of Japanese-American sculptor Isamu Noguchi. The museum features a comprehensive collection of Noguchi’s sculptures, as well as his designs for furniture, gardens, and stage sets. Explore the tranquil sculpture garden and admire the artist’s unique blend of Eastern and Western influences. The Noguchi Museum is a hidden gem that offers a peaceful and inspiring art experience.

Unique Experiences

Find Something New With Governor’s Island

Governors Island, once a military base, has been transformed into a sprawling park and cultural destination. Take a ferry from Lower Manhattan or Brooklyn and explore this car-free island. Enjoy stunning views of the Statue of Liberty, the Manhattan skyline, and the Brooklyn Bridge. Rent a bike, have a picnic, or explore the historic forts and buildings. Governors Island offers a unique and refreshing escape from the city. There are festivals held here all year round, and it is a great place to bring your family.

Secret Spots

Find A New Favorite Spot at the Elevated Acre

Hidden atop a building in the Financial District, the Elevated Acre is a secret rooftop park that offers stunning views of the East River and the Brooklyn Bridge. This hidden oasis features a lawn, gardens, and a small amphitheater. Take a break from the concrete jungle and enjoy a peaceful moment in this unexpected green space.

Live Like a New Yorker

Use the Subway Like a Pro

Navigating New York City’s subway system like a local is an art form in itself. First, invest in a weekly unlimited MetroCard for the most efficient and cost-effective travel. Download a subway map app on your phone for easy navigation. Be mindful of subway etiquette: stand to the right on escalators, allow passengers to exit before you board, and avoid blocking the doorways. When it comes to non touristy things to do in New York City, travel like the locals.

Shop at Local Grocery Stores

Embrace the New York City experience by ditching the chain supermarkets and exploring local grocery stores. Zabar’s, on the Upper West Side, is a legendary institution that offers a vast selection of gourmet foods, cheeses, and smoked fish. For a taste of Little Italy, head to Di Palo’s Fine Foods on Grand Street and browse their impressive selection of Italian cheeses and cured meats. Shopping at local grocery stores is a great way to support small businesses and discover unique culinary treasures.

Conclusion

New York City is so much more than just its iconic landmarks. By venturing beyond the typical tourist attractions and embracing the city’s hidden gems, you can unlock a truly authentic and unforgettable travel experience. Explore the diverse neighborhoods, indulge in the culinary delights, discover the hidden parks, and immerse yourself in the vibrant arts scene. When you visit the non touristy things to do in New York City, you can unlock a brand new level of fun.

So, ditch the crowds and embrace the authentic side of NYC. You might just find your new favorite hidden gem! Next time you are in New York City, remember that some of the best non touristy things to do in New York City are the ones you discover yourself.

Hopefully this article helps guide you on your journey!