Draft Grades by Team: Analyzing the 2024 NFL Draft Class

Introduction

The National Football League Draft is a spectacle, a three-day rollercoaster of hope, speculation, and, let’s be honest, overanalysis. Each year, thirty-two teams navigate the intricate selection process, hoping to unearth the next generation of gridiron stars. Fans eagerly await each pick, dreaming of future Super Bowl victories fueled by these fresh talents. Immediately following the draft, a flurry of opinions, assessments, and, most notably, draft grades erupt across the media landscape. This article will delve into those draft grades by team, examining how different analysts perceived each franchise’s performance in the latest draft and offering insights into the reasoning behind those evaluations.

It’s crucial to remember that draft grades are, at best, educated guesses. No one truly knows how these young players will adapt to the professional level, handle the pressures of the NFL, or reach their full potential. Injuries, coaching changes, and unforeseen circumstances can all dramatically alter a player’s trajectory. However, draft grades provide a snapshot of immediate reaction, reflecting how well each team addressed their needs, acquired value, and seemingly positioned themselves for future success. We’ll be drawing on evaluations from reputable sources such as ESPN, Pro Football Focus, and CBS Sports to provide a comprehensive overview of draft grades by team. The criteria often used includes how a team addressed their needs, the overall value achieved with each pick, the potential of the players selected, and the overall fit within the team’s existing scheme.

AFC East Team Assessments

Let’s begin our journey through the league, starting with the competitive AFC East.

Buffalo Bills Draft Analysis

The Buffalo Bills entered the draft with clear objectives: bolster their receiving corps and address some defensive concerns. The consensus on their draft grades suggests they had a solid, if not spectacular, performance. The initial assessments placed them around the middle of the pack. Many analysts applauded their selection of Keon Coleman, a physical receiver known for his contested catch ability, hoping he can become a reliable target for Josh Allen. Their defense did see some strengthening, with the drafting of linebacker Payton Wilson, though concerns linger about his injury history. Some considered their best value pick to be safety Javon Bullard, while a potential bust, in the eyes of some analysts, could be receiver Cornelius Johnson. Overall, the Bills addressed some immediate needs, but their draft grade reflects a calculated approach rather than a home run swing.

Miami Dolphins Draft Analysis

The Miami Dolphins, known for their speed and offensive firepower, aimed to add depth and versatility to their roster. Their draft grades varied considerably, with some praising their aggressive approach and others questioning their reach on certain selections. Chop Robinson, an edge rusher expected to boost their pass rush, headlines their draft. This pick was considered a reach by some, but the Dolphins clearly valued his potential. Another notable selection was Patrick Paul to protect Tua Tagovailoa. Some have marked tailback Jaylen Wright as a potential bust with a less than desirable history. While the Dolphins took chances, it may be too soon to tell if this risky strategy will pay off.

New England Patriots Draft Analysis

The New England Patriots entered the draft with perhaps the most pressing need of any team: a franchise quarterback. After missing on so many, their performance will be judged almost entirely on the development of Drake Maye. Evaluators are split; many see Maye as a high-ceiling prospect with the potential to become a star, while others question his accuracy and decision-making. Their draft grade largely hinges on Maye’s success. Beyond Maye, the Patriots focused on adding offensive line talent to protect their new quarterback. One player that has stood out amongst analysts is receiver Javon Baker, who seems to have potential to be a value pick.

New York Jets Draft Analysis

The New York Jets, hoping to capitalize on the return of Aaron Rodgers, prioritized offensive line and receiving support. They made a significant move up the board to secure Olu Fashanu, a highly touted offensive tackle. Many experts praised this move, seeing Fashanu as a potential long-term anchor for their offensive line and a crucial protector for their aging quarterback. A few analysts suggest that running back Braelon Allen will be a bust with his injury concerns. Overall, the Jets’ draft was seen as a pragmatic approach to maximizing their Super Bowl window, resulting in generally favorable draft grades.

AFC North Team Assessments

Let’s shift our focus to the rugged AFC North.

Cincinnati Bengals Draft Analysis

The Cincinnati Bengals focused on fortifying their trenches on both sides of the ball. Experts lauded their selection of Amarius Mims, an offensive tackle from Georgia, seeing him as a potential cornerstone for their offensive line. Many analysts believe his size and athleticism will make him an immediate asset in pass protection. They also addressed their defensive line needs. The Bengals appeared to have a solid draft, earning average to above-average grades from most analysts. There is some belief that this was a reach by Cincinnati.

Cleveland Browns Draft Analysis

The Cleveland Browns entered the draft with fewer picks than most teams due to previous trades. Their approach focused on adding depth and developmental prospects. Their top pick, Michael Hall Jr., a defensive tackle, was viewed as a high-upside selection. Evaluators are divided on his immediate impact, but his potential is undeniable. The Browns also looked to add talent at the receiver position, securing Jamari Thrash. Analysts are skeptical on some of the defensive additions, which some believe could be a bust.

Baltimore Ravens Draft Analysis

The Baltimore Ravens, known for their shrewd drafting, once again seemed to find value throughout the draft. Many analysts praised their selection of Nate Wiggins, a cornerback with impressive speed and coverage skills. There are some that believe the cornerbacks will never truly improve the team. They also added depth to their running back room with the addition of Rasheen Ali. Overall, the Ravens’ draft was viewed as a success, earning them high marks for their ability to identify and secure talent at various positions.

Pittsburgh Steelers Draft Analysis

The Pittsburgh Steelers addressed several key needs in the draft, particularly on the offensive side of the ball. The selection of Troy Fautanu was greatly praised, as they are in desperate need of an offensive tackle. They also double-dipped at wide receiver, selecting Roman Wilson. His ability to separate and make tough catches should provide an immediate boost. There is concern that the Steelers reached too much. Overall, the Steelers’ draft was seen as a step in the right direction, earning them positive, if not stellar, grades.

AFC South Team Assessments

Now, let’s move on to the up-and-coming AFC South.

Houston Texans Draft Analysis

The Houston Texans, fresh off a surprising playoff appearance, looked to build on their momentum in the draft. Many analysts lauded their selection of Kamari Lassiter, seeing him as a potential long-term starter and a valuable addition to their secondary. The trade for a pass rusher also earned them high marks. Experts have their concerns around the safety position. Overall, the Texans were viewed as having a very strong draft, with their aggressive moves paying off handsomely in terms of talent acquisition.

Indianapolis Colts Draft Analysis

The Indianapolis Colts entered the draft with the goal of bolstering their defensive front and adding playmakers on offense. There is a wide belief the Colts didn’t come away with any real value, and reached a bit for some of the players they drafted. Adonai Mitchell was a reach, and the rest of the players drafted were not considered game-changers by any stretch of the imagination. This draft has been considered a total failure, with their defensive line not being changed and the offense lacking punch.

Jacksonville Jaguars Draft Analysis

The Jacksonville Jaguars aimed to add explosiveness to their offense and improve their pass rush in the draft. They picked receiver Brian Thomas Jr. and a cornerback to boost the team. Many experts have questioned whether the team reached for the Thomas Jr., and the pass rush is still questionable at best. The Jaguars seemed to stumble greatly, and have many concerns going into next season.

Tennessee Titans Draft Analysis

The Tennessee Titans, in rebuild mode, focused on adding young talent and addressing key needs across their roster. Many analysts viewed JC Latham as a solid addition, even if it was a bit of a reach. The Titans failed to bolster the team for immediate success, and many believe they are a few years away from a shot at being decent.

AFC West Team Assessments

Let’s head west to analyze the AFC West teams.

Denver Broncos Draft Analysis

The Denver Broncos entered the draft with questions at the most important position, quarterback. The Broncos did a terrible job. Many analysts agree they took a quarterback way too high in the draft. The consensus is that the team drafted poorly, and will be one of the worst teams in the NFL going forward.

Kansas City Chiefs Draft Analysis

The Kansas City Chiefs, fresh off another Super Bowl win, looked to add more talent to their already stacked roster. Many praised the Chiefs for drafting Xavier Worthy. This will add much needed help at receiver. Some believe this team will be unstoppable again this year. This draft was widely considered a home run.

Las Vegas Raiders Draft Analysis

The Las Vegas Raiders were said to have drafted well on the offensive side of the ball. The team looked to be on track to turning things around. Whether this draft can propel them into contention is yet to be determined.

Los Angeles Chargers Draft Analysis

The Los Angeles Chargers look to have built a strong defensive unit through the draft. They got an elite talent in Joe Alt, and also added defensive talent on the defensive side of the ball. This team could be a force to be reckoned with moving forward.

NFC East Team Assessments

Moving over to the NFC, let’s start with the competitive NFC East.

Dallas Cowboys Draft Analysis

The Dallas Cowboys seem to have done a great job improving the offense. With the additions of Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe, they added some much needed reinforcements on the offensive line, improving the offense. While the team is not a favorite to win the Super Bowl, they are expected to make a strong push.

New York Giants Draft Analysis

The New York Giants had a great first round, and the team seems to be improving. Experts are split on their grade, but most seem to give them above average grade. How the team comes together will be a question going forward.

Philadelphia Eagles Draft Analysis

The Philadelphia Eagles draft has the potential to be one of the best in the entire league. With Howie Roseman running the draft, it is usually a success, and this year seems to be a repeat of that fact. There are few critics with this draft.

Washington Commanders Draft Analysis

The Washington Commanders improved at the most important position, selecting quarterback Jayden Daniels with the second overall pick. There is a bit of skepticism on if they can protect their investment, but the Commanders overall draft seems to be a success.

NFC North Team Assessments

Heading north, let’s assess the NFC North teams.

Chicago Bears Draft Analysis

The Chicago Bears might be the draft champions. With the addition of Caleb Williams, the team has a chance to become a juggernaut. They also took Rome Odunze, giving Williams another weapon to utilize.

Detroit Lions Draft Analysis

The Detroit Lions had a solid draft, addressing the defensive side of the ball. With this draft, the Lions addressed some needs and added quality players.

Green Bay Packers Draft Analysis

The Green Bay Packers took great value in the draft and didn’t reach. With this type of draft, there is not much to complain about, with analysts saying that they did a great job improving the overall roster.

Minnesota Vikings Draft Analysis

The Minnesota Vikings spent a lot of assets to draft quarterback JJ McCarthy. There are questions on if he is good enough to lead the team to the promised land, but there is a chance that the Vikings have finally found their future franchise quarterback.

NFC South Team Assessments

Heading south, let’s analyze the NFC South teams.

Atlanta Falcons Draft Analysis

The Atlanta Falcons selecting quarterback Michael Penix Jr. made absolutely no sense, considering that the team just paid Kirk Cousins. While the team believes he is the future, many question their sanity. This will go down as one of the worst draft picks in NFL history if Cousins continues to perform, as the lost asset will be seen as a waste.

Carolina Panthers Draft Analysis

The Carolina Panthers focused on the wrong positions, leaving a lot to be desired. Some believe this draft will be the team’s undoing.

New Orleans Saints Draft Analysis

The New Orleans Saints did a good job finding value. While their future success is not guaranteed, the team has a chance to become a strong competitor.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers Draft Analysis

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers did a good job drafting defensive talent. There are some questions regarding the team’s future success, but the team is set up to be okay. Experts believe that they need a lot more help to truly compete.

NFC West Team Assessments

Finally, let’s wrap up with the NFC West.

Arizona Cardinals Draft Analysis

The Arizona Cardinals drafted receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. He is one of the most talented players in the draft, and the team will have a quality player to look forward to. They are set to be a team to be reckoned with in the future.

Los Angeles Rams Draft Analysis

The Los Angeles Rams had an average draft. They look to be mediocre for quite some time. This draft was ok, but nothing to write home about.

San Francisco 49ers Draft Analysis

The San Francisco 49ers added more talent to an already stacked team. They selected Ricky Pearsall. The team continues to add weapons to their offense, and continues to improve. This was a great draft.

Seattle Seahawks Draft Analysis

The Seattle Seahawks focused on improving the defense. With that improvement, the team will look to contend in the near future. The team added several key pieces.

Comprehensive Evaluation of Draft Grades by Team

Having sifted through the draft grades by team, several overarching trends emerge. There appeared to be a league-wide emphasis on addressing offensive line needs, reflecting the growing importance of protecting quarterbacks in today’s NFL. Many teams also prioritized adding explosive playmakers on offense, targeting wide receivers and running backs with game-changing potential.

Teams with the Most Praised Drafts

A few teams stood out as receiving particularly high praise for their draft hauls. One such team was the Philadelphia Eagles. Their ability to consistently find value throughout the draft, particularly on the defensive side of the ball, earned them rave reviews. Another team frequently mentioned among the “winners” was the Kansas City Chiefs. Their selection of Xavier Worthy was thought to be a great addition. They did a great job adding some protection to Patrick Mahomes.

Teams Facing Draft Grade Scrutiny

Conversely, some teams faced more criticism for their draft performances. The Denver Broncos draft seemed to be questioned the most. They selected Bo Nix, who was said to be a reach by many, with a pick that was far too high. The Carolina Panthers faced some harsh judgements. They focused on a player in a position that was already one of the strongest on their team, neglecting other dire needs.

Draft Surprises and Unexpected Moves

The draft wasn’t without its surprises. The Atlanta Falcons selecting Michael Penix Jr. when they just paid Kirk Cousins a fortune. There were many trade-ups and trade-downs that shifted the landscape of the draft.

The Long-Term Assessment of Draft Grades

Ultimately, draft grades are a temporary reflection of immediate impressions. The true measure of a draft class’s success will be determined over the coming years, as these young players develop and contribute to their respective teams. Some seemingly brilliant draft picks will flame out, while others will exceed all expectations. The best teams consistently find ways to identify and develop talent, regardless of where players are drafted. It takes time to see the overall impact of any team’s draft.

As we wrap up this analysis of draft grades by team, one thing remains clear: the NFL Draft is a complex and unpredictable process. While these initial assessments provide valuable insights and fuel fan excitement, the real story of the latest draft class will unfold on the field in the years to come. The journey to the Super Bowl begins now, and these newly drafted players will play a crucial role in shaping the league’s landscape.