Discovering the Thirty-Seven Best Restaurants in Williamsburg, New York City
Williamsburg isn’t just a Brooklyn neighborhood; it’s a vibrant, ever-evolving culinary landscape. Forget your map – prepare to dive headfirst into a world where Michelin-starred chefs mingle with hole-in-the-wall taco joints, and where the aroma of freshly baked bread competes with the tangy scent of kimchi. Ready to explore thirty-seven of the best dining experiences this Brooklyn gem has to offer?
From its industrial roots to its current status as a haven for artists and foodies alike, Williamsburg’s evolution is palpable. Its dining scene mirrors this transformation, boasting a diverse range of cuisines, ambiances, and price points. Whether you’re seeking a romantic candlelit dinner, a casual brunch with friends, or an adventurous exploration of global flavors, Williamsburg promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more.
This isn’t just another list; it’s your curated guide to the top eateries in Williamsburg. We’ve scoured the neighborhood, considered the opinions of locals, and meticulously analyzed reviews to bring you a selection of restaurants that stand out from the crowd. While “best” is subjective, this compilation prioritizes quality, ambiance, value, popularity, and recent accolades. Prepare your appetite; Williamsburg awaits.
Culinary Adventures: Exploring Williamsburg’s Best Bites
Navigating the restaurant scene in Williamsburg can feel overwhelming. That’s why we’ve organized this guide to help you find the perfect spot, whatever your craving.
Italian Indulgence
Williamsburg boasts a collection of Italian restaurants that transport you straight to the heart of Italy. From classic trattorias to modern interpretations, these spots offer an authentic taste of la dolce vita.
Lilia
This is more than a restaurant; it’s an experience. Chef Missy Robbins’ pasta dishes are legendary, crafted with simple ingredients and bursting with flavor. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for a special occasion. The mafaldini is a must-try, as is anything from the wood-fired grill. The price point reflects the quality and experience. Locals whisper about getting a reservation weeks in advance. Must-try dishes are the Mafaldini and Cacio e Pepe.
Antica Pesa
A transplant from Rome, Antica Pesa brings a touch of old-world elegance to Williamsburg. The food is refined, the service impeccable, and the wine list extensive. Try the classic Roman dishes, prepared with the freshest seasonal ingredients. Their outdoor garden is a hidden oasis. Consider this a higher-end option for a truly memorable meal. Must-try dishes are the Cacio e Pepe and the Osso Buco.
American Classics, Elevated
From perfectly cooked burgers to innovative takes on comfort food, Williamsburg’s American restaurants offer something for everyone.
Peter Luger Steak House
An institution. While technically in South Williamsburg, its reputation precedes it. This old-school steakhouse is a meat lover’s paradise, serving up perfectly aged and charred steaks. The atmosphere is classic and no-frills, focused entirely on the quality of the beef. Expect to share and don’t forget the thick-cut bacon. Locals recommend making a reservation far in advance, and bringing cash. Must-try dishes are the Porterhouse Steak and the Thick-Cut Bacon.
Diner
This iconic restaurant, housed in a refurbished Pullman dining car, is a Williamsburg landmark. The menu changes daily, highlighting seasonal ingredients and creative cooking. It’s a great spot for a casual but memorable meal. Everything is written on the butcher paper tablecloth. Must-try dishes are whatever the daily specials are!
Asian Sensations: A World of Flavors
Explore the vibrant and diverse world of Asian cuisine in Williamsburg, from delicate sushi to spicy curries.
Okonomi
This Japanese restaurant specializes in authentic breakfast and lunch sets, offering a taste of traditional Japanese home cooking. The fish is incredibly fresh, and the rice is perfectly cooked. Prepare to queue, as it’s a small space and extremely popular. Their Salmon Donburi is a local favorite. Must-try dishes are the Salmon Donburi and the Miso Soup.
Luce
Offering delicious vietnamese cuisine. The summer rolls are delicious and fresh. Must-try dishes are the Pho and Summer Rolls
Mexican Fiesta: Tacos, Tequila, and More
Spice up your life with the bold flavors of Mexico at Williamsburg’s top Mexican restaurants.
XOLO
This isn’t just tacos; it’s a celebration of authentic Mexican flavors with a modern Williamsburg twist. Their al pastor tacos are legendary, and the margarita selection is seriously impressive. The open kitchen adds to the lively atmosphere, and the staff is incredibly friendly. The mole is rich and complex, a true highlight. The atmosphere is usually energetic. Must-try dishes are the Al Pastor Tacos and Mole Poblano.
Brunch Bliss: The Perfect Weekend Ritual
Williamsburg is synonymous with brunch, and these restaurants offer the perfect way to start your weekend.
Five Leaves
This Australian-inspired café is a Williamsburg institution, known for its ricotta pancakes and relaxed atmosphere. The outdoor seating is perfect for people-watching, and the coffee is excellent. Expect a wait, especially on weekends. Local’s Tip: Arrive early to avoid the longest queues. The ricotta pancakes are a must! Must-try dishes are the Ricotta Pancakes and the Avocado Toast.
Egg
A charming spot dedicated to breakfast and brunch. They make a great biscuit and use farm fresh ingredients. Must-try dishes are the biscuits and eggs.
Pizza Perfection: From Classic to Creative
No trip to Williamsburg is complete without a slice (or two) of pizza. These restaurants offer a variety of styles, from classic Neapolitan to innovative creations.
Roberta’s Pizza
This legendary pizzeria is a must-visit for any pizza lover. The wood-fired pies are cooked to perfection, with a crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The atmosphere is lively and casual, perfect for a group outing. It’s located a short walk or train ride away but totally worth it. Must-try dishes are the Bee Sting and the Margherita Pizza.
L’Industrie Pizzeria
Big slices, affordable prices. This spot has been getting a lot of attention lately for their generous slices and tasty combinations. Their crust is thin and crispy and they are constantly coming up with new specials. Must-try dishes are the Burrata Slice and the Pepperoni Slice
A Deeper Dive into Deliciousness: More Standout Spots
Beyond the categories above, here are some other Williamsburg restaurants that deserve a spot on your culinary radar.
Aska
For a truly exceptional dining experience, Aska is a must. This two-Michelin-starred restaurant offers a refined tasting menu that showcases the best of Scandinavian cuisine. The presentation is artful, the service impeccable, and the flavors unforgettable. This is a splurge, but worth it for a special occasion.
The Four Horsemen
This natural wine bar and restaurant is a favorite among locals. The menu features seasonal dishes that are designed to pair perfectly with the wine list. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, perfect for a casual night out. Owned by James Murphy of LCD Soundsystem.
Sunday in Brooklyn
A three-story restaurant with a variety of offerings. Everything is well-executed. The cocktails are great.
Deus Ex Machina
A motorcycle shop with a cafe and restaurant in the back! Enjoy the vibes.
Nami Nori
Taco style sushi. It is incredibly delicious and makes for a great date spot.
Misi
Sister restaurant to Lilia. Another delicious pasta spot from Missy Robbins. Prepare for a wait!
Meadowsweet
A refined American spot. Great for a date night!
St. Anselm
Meat-centric restaurant. A great place to go with friends and share a bunch of appetizers and grilled meats.
Traif
Delicious spot serving non-kosher food in a Kosher neighborhood. Try the bacon doughnuts!
Aurora
A charming italian restaurant in the heart of Williamsburg.
Le Crocodile
Classic French fare.
The Modern
A hip american spot.
Westlight
Rooftop bar and restaurant with amazing views.
Local’s Secrets: Insider Tips for the Best Experience
Throughout your Williamsburg culinary adventure, keep these insider tips in mind:
Timing is Everything: Avoid peak hours, especially on weekends, to minimize wait times. Many restaurants offer lunch specials or happy hour deals.
Reservations are Key: For popular restaurants, especially those with smaller spaces, make reservations well in advance.
Explore Beyond Bedford: While Bedford Avenue is the main thoroughfare, don’t be afraid to venture off the beaten path. Some of the best hidden gems are located on side streets.
Embrace the Diversity: Williamsburg’s culinary scene is incredibly diverse. Be open to trying new cuisines and dishes.
Don’t Forget the Drinks: Williamsburg is home to a number of excellent bars and breweries. Pair your meal with a local craft beer or a handcrafted cocktail.
Local’s Tip: Many restaurants offer takeout or delivery options, perfect for a cozy night in.
Local’s Tip: Check restaurant websites and social media pages for special events, promotions, and menu updates.
More delicious locations:
Tacocina
The Butcher’s Daughter
Sweet Chick
Birds of a Feather
Win Son Bakery
Ten Hope Cocktail Bar
M Shanghai
Union Pool
Devocion
Freehold Brooklyn
Suzume
A Final Bite: Savoring the Williamsburg Experience
Williamsburg’s food scene is a testament to the neighborhood’s creativity, diversity, and unwavering spirit. From Michelin-starred restaurants to casual cafes, there’s something for every palate and budget. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or a curious explorer, Williamsburg promises a culinary adventure that you won’t soon forget.
So, grab your appetite, lace up your walking shoes, and prepare to discover the best restaurants Williamsburg has to offer. Explore the flavors, embrace the atmosphere, and share your own favorite finds in the comments below. Williamsburg’s culinary story is constantly evolving, and we invite you to be a part of it. Your next unforgettable meal is waiting just around the corner. Enjoy!
