25 Most Favorite Restaurants in Upper West Side, New York: A Culinary Journey

Introduction

The Upper West Side (UWS) of New York City is a neighborhood that hums with life, a place where history, culture, and a vibrant community converge. Nestled between Central Park and Riverside Park, this iconic area isn’t just about stunning architecture and world-class museums; it’s also a culinary paradise. From cozy cafes to elegant dining rooms, the Upper West Side offers a dining experience for every palate and occasion. It’s a haven for food lovers, both locals and tourists alike, all searching for the perfect bite.

This article takes you on a delectable journey through the heart of the Upper West Side, spotlighting the most beloved and highly-rated restaurants the neighborhood has to offer. Consider this your curated guide to the culinary gems that make the UWS such a special place to dine. We’ve carefully selected these eateries based on their popularity, rave reviews, unique atmosphere, and the unforgettable flavors they bring to the table. Get ready to discover your new favorite spot for that perfect meal, from morning bagels to late-night desserts.

Categories

Best Bagels
Best Pizza
Best Brunch
Best Sushi
Best Steak
Best Italian Food

The List: Most Favorite Restaurants in the Upper West Side

Bagel Bliss at Absolute Bagels

A true Upper West Side institution, Absolute Bagels is renowned for its freshly baked, chewy bagels that are consistently ranked among the best in the city. Expect a line (it moves quickly!), but know that it’s absolutely worth the wait. Their bagels are perfectly crispy on the outside, soft and fluffy on the inside, and simply divine with a generous schmear of cream cheese.
“The best bagels in the city, hands down! Always fresh and the service is quick and friendly.”

Pizza Perfection at Mama’s TOO!

Mama’s TOO! is more than just a pizza place; it’s a testament to the art of crafting the perfect slice. Their unique, rectangular pizzas are known for their crispy, airy crust, topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or something more adventurous, Mama’s TOO! will leave you wanting more.
“This pizza is a game-changer. The crust is incredible, and the toppings are always creative and delicious.”

Sunday Funday Brunch at Sarabeth’s

Sarabeth’s is synonymous with brunch in New York City, and their Upper West Side location is a perennial favorite. Their menu boasts a wide array of classic brunch dishes, from fluffy omelets and pancakes to eggs benedict and french toast. With its charming atmosphere and impeccable service, Sarabeth’s is the perfect spot to start your Sunday.
“Sarabeth’s is always a great experience. The food is consistently delicious, and the atmosphere is so warm and inviting.”

Sushi Sensations at Sushi Yasaka

Sushi Yasaka is a true gem for sushi lovers in the Upper West Side. They are known for their fresh, high-quality fish, expertly prepared into stunning and flavorful sushi and sashimi. Their omakase (chef’s choice) is an excellent way to experience the full range of their offerings.
“The sushi here is amazing! The fish is so fresh, and the presentation is beautiful. A must-try for any sushi fan.”

Steakhouse Excellence at The Smith

The Smith is a bustling brasserie with a lively atmosphere, and their Upper West Side location is a popular destination for steak lovers. Their steaks are cooked to perfection, and their menu also includes a variety of other classic American dishes, such as burgers, seafood, and pasta.
“The Smith is always a fun place to go. The food is great, the drinks are strong, and the atmosphere is buzzing.”

Italian Indulgence at Celeste

Celeste serves up classic Italian fare in a cozy, intimate setting. Their handmade pastas are a highlight, as are their wood-fired pizzas and flavorful entrees. With its romantic atmosphere and attentive service, Celeste is the perfect spot for a special occasion.
“Celeste is one of my favorite restaurants in the UWS. The food is always amazing, and the atmosphere is so romantic.”

French Flair at Cafe Luxembourg

A classic French brasserie, Cafe Luxembourg has been a fixture of the Upper West Side for decades. Their menu features traditional French dishes, such as steak frites, escargots, and bouillabaisse, all prepared with impeccable attention to detail.
“Cafe Luxembourg is a true classic. The food is always excellent, and the atmosphere is so chic and sophisticated.”

Casual Comfort at Shake Shack

Sometimes, all you need is a great burger and fries. Shake Shack delivers on this promise with their juicy burgers, crispy crinkle-cut fries, and creamy milkshakes. Their Upper West Side location is a popular spot for a quick and satisfying meal.
“Shake Shack is always a good choice for a quick and easy meal. The burgers are delicious, and the fries are addictive.”

Sweet Treats at Levain Bakery

Levain Bakery is famous for their oversized, gooey cookies that are legendary in New York City. Their Upper West Side location is always bustling with customers eager to get their hands on these delectable treats.
“Levain cookies are the best! They’re so big, gooey, and decadent. A must-try for any cookie lover.”

Mediterranean Magic at Hummus Place

Hummus Place is a casual spot serving up authentic Middle Eastern cuisine, with a focus on hummus. Their hummus is creamy, flavorful, and served with warm pita bread and a variety of toppings.
“The hummus here is incredible! It’s so smooth, creamy, and flavorful. A great spot for a quick and healthy meal.”

Authentic Thai at Land Thai Kitchen

Craving some authentic Thai food? Land Thai Kitchen offers a wide array of classic Thai dishes, from pad thai and green curry to tom yum soup and spicy noodles. Their dishes are flavorful, authentic, and reasonably priced.
“Land Thai is my go-to for Thai food in the UWS. The food is always delicious, and the service is quick and friendly.”

Tavern Charm at Amsterdam Tavern

Amsterdam Tavern offers American cuisine and an assortment of beers. This place is very popular among locals and families for its laid-back vibes.
“One of the best places to eat a nice burger.”

Mexican Flavors at Playa Betty’s

Playa Betty’s brings the taste of Southern California to the Upper West Side. Their menu features a variety of tacos, burritos, and other Mexican-inspired dishes, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
“Playa Betty’s is always a fun place to go. The food is great, the drinks are strong, and the atmosphere is lively.”

Indian Spices at Awadh

Awadh is a celebrated Indian eatery on the Upper West Side. The restaurant is very popular for their biryanis and curries.
“The biryani is very good and flavorful”

Latin Heat at Calle Ocho

Calle Ocho brings Latin flavors to the Upper West Side in a vibrant and energetic setting. Their menu boasts a wide array of Latin American dishes, from ceviche and empanadas to paella and grilled meats.
“Calle Ocho is a great place to celebrate. The food is delicious, the drinks are strong, and the atmosphere is festive.”

Old World Charm at Barney Greengrass

Barney Greengrass is an Upper West Side institution, serving up classic Jewish deli fare since 1908. Their smoked fish, bagels, and sandwiches are legendary, and their old-world charm makes it a truly unique dining experience.
“Barney Greengrass is a true gem. The food is always delicious, and the atmosphere is so authentic.”

A Taste of France at Boulud Sud

From Michelin star chef Daniel Boulud, this Mediterranean eatery features dishes with flavors from the entirety of the Mediterranean.
“Boulud Sud is an Upper West Side gem. The food is always excellent, and the atmosphere is so authentic.”

Southern Comfort at Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que brings the taste of the South to the Upper West Side with their slow-smoked meats, savory sides, and lively atmosphere. Their ribs, pulled pork, and brisket are legendary, and their live music makes it a fun place to hang out.
“Dinosaur Bar-B-Que is a great place to go for some good old-fashioned barbecue. The meat is always tender and flavorful, and the sides are delicious.”

Coffee Break at Joe Coffee Company

Joe Coffee Company is a specialty coffee shop serving up expertly crafted coffee drinks, pastries, and light bites. Their Upper West Side location is a popular spot for a caffeine fix or a quick snack.
“Joe Coffee is my go-to for coffee in the UWS. The coffee is always excellent, and the baristas are friendly and knowledgeable.”

Italian Excellence at Pappardella

Known for it’s red sauce and lively atmosphere, this is a great place to enjoy a hearty Italian meal with family and friends.
“The atmosphere here is amazing, and the food is just as good.”

Seafood Sensation at Citarella

Citarella is a seafood lover’s paradise, with a wide array of fresh fish, shellfish, and prepared dishes. Their Upper West Side location also has a cafe where you can enjoy a casual meal of seafood dishes.
“Citarella is the best place to get fresh seafood in the UWS. The quality is always excellent, and the selection is amazing.”

Mediterranean Delight at Maoz Vegetarian

For an enjoyable meal of Middle-Eastern cuisine, Maoz Vegetarian should definitely be on your list. Their Falafel is very popular for it’s rich flavors.
“Amazing place with a great variety of fresh vegetables and their falafel is out of this world!”

Delicious Pizza at Corvo

Corvo has made its name as a hidden gem and great neighborhood restaurant.
“Very good pizza in the neighborhood, definitely should be on your list!”

European Flair at Good Enough To Eat

This European themed restaurant is an all-time favorite for its amazing food, kind stuff and friendly vibes.
“Great place to enjoy dinner with friends, the atmosphere is cozy and the food is just amazing!”

Map

[Insert embeddable google map here with all locations pinned]

Conclusion

The Upper West Side offers a culinary adventure for every taste and budget. From iconic institutions to hidden gems, the restaurants listed above represent the best of what this vibrant neighborhood has to offer. We’ve highlighted a diverse range of cuisines and dining experiences, hoping to provide a comprehensive guide to the UWS food scene. Now, it’s your turn to explore! Discover your own favorites, try something new, and savor the incredible flavors of the Upper West Side. We encourage you to check their websites to make reservations.

Remember, this list is just a starting point. The Upper West Side is brimming with culinary treasures waiting to be discovered. We invite you to share your own recommendations in the comments below – what are your favorite UWS restaurants? What dishes do you swear by? Let’s create a community of food lovers and continue to explore the ever-evolving culinary landscape of the Upper West Side!