The Thirty-Eight Best Mexican Restaurants in New York City
New York City, a melting pot of cultures and cuisines, pulsates with culinary energy. Among the diverse offerings, Mexican food shines brightly, offering a vibrant tapestry of flavors, aromas, and traditions. From humble street tacos to sophisticated mole dishes, the city’s Mexican scene is a journey for the palate. Navigating this vast landscape can be overwhelming, but fear not! This guide cuts through the noise, presenting the thirty-eight best Mexican restaurants in New York City, each promising a unique and unforgettable experience.
Mexican cuisine in New York isn’t just about tacos and burritos – though those are certainly well-represented. It’s a celebration of regional specialties, from the smoky richness of Oaxacan mole to the fiery flavors of Yucatecan cochinita pibil. You’ll find chefs honoring ancestral techniques alongside those pushing the boundaries of modern Mexican gastronomy. Whether you’re craving a casual bite with friends, a romantic dinner for two, or a family fiesta, the perfect Mexican restaurant awaits.
This list reflects a careful curation process. We’ve considered a multitude of factors, including expert reviews from food critics, passionate recommendations from local residents, overwhelmingly positive online ratings, and of course, our own dedicated exploration of the city’s Mexican food scene. Authenticity, quality of ingredients, overall atmosphere, exceptional service, and value for money were all key criteria in our selections. Now, let’s embark on this culinary adventure!
Mexican Marvels in Manhattan
Manhattan, the heart of New York City, offers a stunning array of Mexican dining options. From trendy downtown spots to hidden uptown gems, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your cravings.
Los Tacos No. 1
This popular taqueria, with multiple locations across Manhattan, earns its spot with its consistently delicious and authentic tacos. Their al pastor, marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit, is a must-try. The simple menu, focused on quality ingredients and expertly executed classics, is a testament to their success. Don’t be surprised by the lines; they move quickly, and the tacos are worth the wait. Expect a bustling, casual atmosphere and budget-friendly prices.
Cosme
For a more upscale experience, Cosme presents a modern interpretation of Mexican cuisine. Chef Enrique Olvera, renowned for his Pujol restaurant in Mexico City, elevates traditional dishes with innovative techniques and refined flavors. Their duck carnitas is a signature dish, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. The ambiance is sophisticated and stylish, perfect for a special occasion. Be prepared for a higher price point and reservations are strongly recommended.
Tacombi
Tacombi, with its vibrant, beach-inspired decor, brings the spirit of Mexico to multiple locations in Manhattan. Their tacos are a crowd-pleaser, with a variety of fillings to choose from, from traditional carnitas to crispy fish. The atmosphere is lively and fun, making it a great spot for a casual meal with friends. They also offer a selection of refreshing aguas frescas and Mexican beers. Prices are reasonable, making it an accessible option for everyone.
Atla
This all-day cafe and restaurant offers a modern take on Mexican breakfast and brunch. From huevos rancheros to chilaquiles, Atla’s menu is full of comforting and flavorful dishes. The restaurant also features a selection of small plates and tacos, perfect for a light lunch or dinner. The atmosphere is bright and airy, making it a pleasant spot to enjoy a meal any time of day.
Cafe El Presidente
Located near Union Square, Cafe El Presidente offers an extensive menu of traditional Mexican dishes, from enchiladas to mole poblano. The restaurant’s vibrant decor and friendly service create a welcoming atmosphere. They also have a great selection of margaritas and other Mexican cocktails.
More Manhattan Must-Tries:
La Esquina: Known for its secret taqueria located behind a unmarked door.
Empellon Al Pastor: Focused solely on al pastor tacos, done exceptionally well.
Oxomoco: A Michelin-starred restaurant featuring wood-fired Mexican cuisine.
El Vez: A trendy spot with a great happy hour and lively atmosphere.
Rosa Mexicano: A classic choice for upscale Mexican dining with beautiful decor.
Brooklyn’s Burgeoning Mexican Scene
Brooklyn’s Mexican food scene is as diverse and dynamic as the borough itself. From authentic taquerias to innovative restaurants, Brooklyn offers a wide range of options for Mexican food lovers.
La Superior
This Williamsburg taqueria is a local favorite, known for its simple but delicious tacos. The tortillas are made fresh daily, and the fillings are flavorful and authentic. The atmosphere is casual and unassuming, making it a great spot for a quick and affordable meal.
Xolo
Located in Park Slope, Xolo offers a modern take on Mexican cuisine. The menu features creative dishes that showcase the chef’s talent and creativity. The atmosphere is stylish and sophisticated, making it a great spot for a date night or special occasion.
Grand Morelos
This Bushwick gem offers authentic Pueblan cuisine. Known for their moles, which are rich, complex sauces made with a variety of chilies, spices, and chocolate, Grand Morelos provides a deep dive into the culinary traditions of the region.
More Brooklyn Bites:
Claro: Oaxacan-inspired cuisine with a focus on seasonal ingredients.
Fonda: Classic Mexican dishes in a cozy and inviting setting.
Maya Taqueria: A neighborhood favorite for quick, delicious, and affordable tacos.
Chavela’s: A popular spot for brunch and Mexican comfort food.
Santa Ana Deli & Grocery: A truly authentic taqueria attached to a grocery store.
Queens: The Undiscovered Mexican Culinary Frontier
Queens is arguably the most authentic Mexican food destination in New York City. This borough offers a wealth of hidden gems, from family-run taquerias to regional specialty restaurants.
Casa Enrique
This Michelin-starred restaurant in Long Island City offers sophisticated Mexican cuisine from Chef Cosme Aguilar. The menu features traditional dishes with a modern twist, showcasing the chef’s talent and creativity. The atmosphere is elegant and refined, making it a great spot for a special occasion.
Tulcingo Del Valle
Located in Jackson Heights, Tulcingo Del Valle is a hidden gem that specializes in Pueblan cuisine. The menu features a wide variety of traditional dishes, from mole poblano to cemitas. The atmosphere is casual and authentic, making it a great spot to experience the real flavors of Mexico.
More Queens Quests:
Itacate: A tiny, family-run spot serving up some of the best huaraches in the city.
Tortilleria Nixtamal: Serves freshly made tortillas and authentic Mexican food.
El Gato Negro: A neighborhood favorite for delicious and affordable tacos.
Bronx & Staten Island:
Bronx
Mexicosina: Authentic dishes from Puebla.
Staten Island
Besito Mexican: A festive atmosphere.
Spotlight: Tacos, Tacos, Tacos!
Let’s face it: no exploration of Mexican food is complete without a deep dive into tacos. Here are a few of the very best places to get your taco fix in New York City:
Los Tacos No. 1: Consistently ranked among the best for a reason. Their al pastor is legendary, and their carne asada is equally satisfying.
Tacombi: A fun and vibrant spot with a wide variety of taco fillings to choose from.
La Superior: Simple but delicious tacos with fresh tortillas and flavorful fillings.
Magnificent Margaritas
What better way to complement your Mexican meal than with a perfectly crafted margarita? Here are a few restaurants that excel in the margarita department:
El Vez: Known for its extensive margarita menu and lively happy hour.
Rosa Mexicano: Offers a variety of creative margaritas with a focus on fresh ingredients.
Vegan & Vegetarian Visions
For those seeking plant-based Mexican options, here are a few restaurants that offer delicious and satisfying vegan and vegetarian dishes:
Oxomoco: Offers a variety of creative vegetarian dishes with a focus on seasonal ingredients.
Atla: Features a selection of vegan and vegetarian small plates and tacos.
Conclusion
New York City’s Mexican food scene is a vibrant and exciting culinary landscape, offering something for every taste and budget. From authentic taquerias to upscale restaurants, the city’s Mexican eateries are sure to delight and satisfy. Whether you’re craving a quick taco, a leisurely brunch, or a celebratory dinner, explore this list and discover your new favorite Mexican restaurant in New York City. The possibilities are endless, and the flavors are unforgettable. So, go forth, explore, and indulge in the deliciousness that awaits!
If we missed your favorite, be sure to let us know in the comments below! Your suggestions help us keep this list updated and reflective of the ever-evolving New York City food scene. ¡Buen provecho!
