Was Eren Really in Control? The Truth About Eren’s Titan Powers and the Rumbling

Introduction

Eren Yeager’s transformation from a vengeful young boy to the architect of the Rumbling stands as one of the most defining and controversial narratives within *Attack on Titan*. The sheer scale of devastation he unleashed, the weight of his decisions, and the ambiguity surrounding his true motivations have left fans debating a crucial question: attack on titan was eren able to control all titans? Was Eren truly in control, or was he a puppet of fate, a vessel for a power too great for any single individual to master? This exploration seeks to delve into the complex nature of Eren’s Titan abilities, particularly those granted by the Founding Titan, and dissect the degree to which he exercised dominion over the swarms of Colossal Titans that ravaged the world. The Rumbling was not simply a display of raw power; it was a manifestation of the will of the Founding Titan, and the extent to which Eren could bend that will to his own remains a central point of contention.

This article will dissect the intricacies of the Founding Titan’s powers, Eren’s initial struggles with them, and the concept of Paths which connected him to past and future. Eren’s story explores determinism versus free will, and the impact his choices had on his loved ones. By investigating these elements, we can develop a deeper understanding of the limits of Eren’s control, and how his inner demons ultimately affected him.

Eren’s Titan Prowess

The linchpin of Eren’s power lies in the Founding Titan, an entity of immense potential capable of manipulating the memories and biological makeup of Eldians, as well as commanding Pure Titans with unmatched authority. This power, however, did not come naturally to Eren. His initial attempts to harness it, as seen during the confrontation in the Reiss family cavern, were fraught with failure. He lacked the royal bloodline, a presumed prerequisite for unlocking the Titan’s full potential. It was only in the face of overwhelming desperation, when Dina Fritz, the Titan who had consumed his mother, approached his friends, that Eren unconsciously awakened the Founding Titan’s abilities, directing nearby Titans to attack her. This pivotal moment revealed the latent power within him, a power that would ultimately define his destiny.

Furthermore, Ymir Fritz, the original Titan, played a significant role in Eren’s access to the Founding Titan. Ymir’s dedication to the royal family prevented the Founding Titan from being used to its full potential. Eren needed to “free” Ymir from her centuries-long servitude in order to obtain access to the Founding Titan. This concept adds another layer to Eren’s control, revealing the importance of spiritual and emotional liberation.

Analyzing Eren’s Control during the Rumbling

The Rumbling, an event of unprecedented devastation, involved the unleashing of countless Colossal Titans, an army that blotted out the sun and shook the very foundations of the world. The scale alone raises serious questions about the practicality of maintaining direct, conscious control over each individual Titan. While evidence suggests that Eren could, to some degree, dictate the overall direction and purpose of the Rumbling, the degree to which he influenced each Titan’s actions remains uncertain. Did Eren truly micromanage the movement of every Titan, or did he simply set them on a predetermined path of destruction, relying on their inherent instincts to carry out his will?

Consider the sheer logistics of commanding such a vast force. Could Eren’s consciousness truly encompass and direct the actions of thousands upon thousands of individual beings, each driven by primal urges and a desire to consume humans? It is plausible that Eren exerted a form of generalized control, setting the Titans in motion and allowing their collective momentum to carry them forward. However, questions arise as to whether individual Pure Titans exhibited any degree of independent behavior or acted in ways that deviated from Eren’s intended plan. Could it be argued that Eren instigated the Rumbling but had little control over its ultimate outcome? These points emphasize that, at times, Eren’s control was limited to guiding the overall direction.

The Significance of Paths and Predetermined Fate

Central to understanding the limits of Eren’s power is the concept of “Paths,” an otherworldly dimension that connects all Eldians and Titans across time and space. Through Paths, Eren could communicate with past inheritors of the Attack Titan and the Founding Titan, and potentially glimpse into the future. This raises a profound question: Did Eren truly make his own choices, or was he simply following a path laid out for him by those who came before?

The idea of predetermined history looms large over the narrative of *Attack on Titan*. Some argue that Eren saw visions of the future and, rather than attempting to alter them, chose to fulfill them, believing that the Rumbling was the only way to secure the future of Paradis Island. This perspective suggests that Eren’s control over the Titans was not absolute but rather constrained by the weight of destiny. He may have been able to direct the Rumbling in certain ways, but the overarching course of events was, in a sense, already set in motion.

This ties into the larger philosophical debate about determinism versus free will. Did Eren truly have agency over his actions, or was he merely a puppet dancing to the tune of fate? The answer, as with many aspects of *Attack on Titan*, is likely nuanced and open to interpretation. Perhaps Eren possessed a degree of free will within the confines of a predetermined framework, able to make choices that influenced the details but not the overall outcome. attack on titan was eren able to control all titans fully? The concept of Paths presents a significant challenge to the notion of absolute control.

Eren’s Motivation and Internal Strife

To assess the limitations on Eren’s power, we must consider Eren’s reasoning. While protecting the people of Paradis Island was definitely one of his motivators, his true goals were more complex. Eren desired to bring about a world in which his friends could live freely. However, the means he chose were morally ambiguous and cost him, and those around him, greatly.

Beyond the strategic calculations and political considerations, Eren was driven by a complex web of emotions, including a deep-seated desire for freedom, a burning hatred for the world that had taken so much from him, and a profound sense of responsibility for the future of his people. He bore the burden of countless lives on his shoulders, a weight that visibly took its toll on him.

Furthermore, the impact of Mikasa and Armin on Eren’s choice needs to be considered. Eren’s relationship with his friends created inner conflicts within him, and ultimately influenced him to make the choices that he did. Eren’s control over the Titans was affected by both external factors and his internal struggles.

Conclusion

In the end, attack on titan was eren able to control all titans? Eren Yeager’s journey in *Attack on Titan* is a cautionary tale about the allure and peril of absolute power, as well as the intricate relationship between determinism and free will. While he wielded the immense power of the Founding Titan, granting him dominion over countless Titans, his control was ultimately complex and imperfect. His actions were shaped by the will of past Titan shifters, his own internal conflicts, and the constraints of a predetermined course of history.

Eren’s story serves as a reminder that even the most formidable power can be limited by external forces and internal struggles. The series reminds its audience that true freedom involves grappling with impossible decisions and coming to terms with unintended consequences. Though his intentions may have been complex, Eren’s actions are a testament to what one may do to achieve their goals.

Eren’s Titan powers were strong, but were they enough to overcome the limitations he faced? *Attack on Titan* asks us to think about the meaning of control, fate, and the cost of freedom.