34 Most Favorite Bars in Staten Island, New York City: Your Ultimate Guide to SI’s Best Sips
Sip Like an Islander: Exploring Staten Island’s Best Bars
Forget the bright lights of Manhattan for a moment. Did you know that Staten Island, the southernmost borough of New York City, boasts a vibrant and surprisingly diverse bar scene all its own? Often overlooked in favor of its more famous neighbors, Staten Island offers a unique blend of neighborhood pubs, sophisticated lounges, and lively sports bars, providing the perfect backdrop for a memorable night out. Forget the long commutes and exorbitant prices – Staten Island delivers authentic New York flavor with a local twist. This guide unveils three dozen and two of the most beloved and highly-rated bars on the island, ensuring your next evening out is one you won’t soon forget. We’ve considered local popularity, atmosphere, customer reviews, and unique offerings to curate this list of Staten Island’s finest. So, prepare to explore the best watering holes this underrated borough has to offer!
Sláinte! Staten Island’s Favorite Irish Pubs
Few things are as comforting as the warm embrace of an authentic Irish pub, and Staten Island certainly delivers on this front. These establishments are more than just places to grab a pint; they’re community hubs where friends gather, stories are shared, and the craic is always flowing.
Killmeyer’s Old Bavaria Inn
Steeped in history, Killmeyer’s isn’t just an Irish pub, it’s an institution with a distinct German heritage too. With its extensive beer selection, hearty German and Irish fare, and rustic atmosphere, Killmeyer’s has been a Staten Island staple for over a century and a half. It’s a favorite for its historical charm and its ability to transport you to another time and place. Expect a lively atmosphere, especially on weekends.
Ruddy & Dean
More than just an Irish Pub, this popular eatery has live entertainment that is popular with the locals on Staten Island.
The Burbs
More than just a restaurant, you can enjoy a lively Irish pub-like atmosphere.
Game On! Staten Island’s Best Sports Bars
For sports enthusiasts, Staten Island boasts an impressive lineup of sports bars where you can catch all the action surrounded by fellow fans. Expect large screens, plenty of beer on tap, and a lively atmosphere that’s perfect for cheering on your favorite team.
Hooley’s Sports Bar & Grill
Hooley’s is a classic sports bar offering a huge selection of beers on tap, a full menu of classic bar fare, and plenty of screens to catch all the games. It’s a favorite among locals for its lively atmosphere and comfortable setting.
The Dugout
This sports bar has all the TVs you need, great food and daily specials to keep you satisfied as you watch all the action.
MVP Bar & Grill
This popular sports bar on Staten Island offers great food, cold drinks, a fun atmosphere and lots of TV’s to watch your games.
Island Vibes: Staten Island’s Prime Waterfront Bars
Nothing beats enjoying a drink with a stunning waterfront view, and Staten Island boasts a number of bars that offer just that. These spots are perfect for soaking up the sun, enjoying a refreshing cocktail, and taking in the breathtaking scenery.
The Waterfront Crab House
While primarily a restaurant, The Waterfront Crab House boasts a bar area with stunning views of the Arthur Kill. Enjoy fresh seafood, refreshing cocktails, and a relaxed atmosphere. It’s a favorite for its unparalleled views and delicious food.
Angelina’s Ristorante
Nestled on the waterfront, this restaurant offers a beautiful outdoor bar area to sip on a drink and have a tasty meal with fantastic views.
Kill Van Kull Bar & Restaurant
Enjoy a relaxing and waterfront experience at this establishment on Staten Island.
Craft Brews and Good Times: Staten Island’s Premier Breweries and Beer Gardens
Staten Island’s craft beer scene is on the rise, with a number of breweries and beer gardens offering unique and flavorful brews. These spots are perfect for beer aficionados looking to sample local creations and enjoy a relaxed and social atmosphere.
Flagship Brewing Company
Located in Tompkinsville, Flagship Brewing Company is a local favorite known for its wide selection of craft beers brewed on-site. With a spacious taproom and outdoor seating area, it’s the perfect place to sample local brews and soak up the island vibe. It’s a favorite for its dedication to quality and its commitment to the Staten Island community.
Kills Boro Brewing
With a great selection of brews and a cozy atmosphere, Kills Boro Brewing is a favorite among the island for great brews and a friendly place to visit.
Brothers Craft Brewing
Enjoy live music, happy hour, brunch and a cold craft brew with Brothers Craft Brewing in Staten Island.
Mix It Up: Staten Island’s Most Creative Cocktail Lounges
For those seeking a more sophisticated drinking experience, Staten Island boasts a number of cocktail lounges that offer expertly crafted drinks in stylish settings. From classic cocktails to innovative creations, these spots are perfect for a special night out.
The Coupe
This prohibition-style bar has a dark but warm atmosphere. Enjoy fancy cocktails with live music on Staten Island.
Above Rooftop
Located in the Hilton Garden Inn, this is the first bar on Staten Island with a rooftop that you can enjoy drinks on with an uninhibited view.
Atrium Cocktail Lounge
Located in the Staten Island University Hospital, this cocktail lounge has a fantastic environment to enjoy yourself in Staten Island.
Unwind and Uncork: Staten Island’s Finest Wine Bars
Wine lovers rejoice! Staten Island offers a selection of wine bars where you can sample a variety of wines from around the world in a relaxed and intimate setting.
Bordeaux Wine Bar
The perfect place for wine and conversation, Bordeaux Wine Bar is sure to provide a top notch wine experience on Staten Island.
Vinum
Enjoy a comfortable and relaxing atmosphere to taste some delicious wines that they offer on Staten Island.
The Wine Loft
Located in the Hilton Garden Inn, this place is the perfect wine bar to enjoy the evening, located on Staten Island.
Dive In: Staten Island’s Beloved Dive Bars
Sometimes, all you need is a no-frills, down-to-earth dive bar to unwind and enjoy a cold one. Staten Island has its fair share of these neighborhood staples, offering a relaxed atmosphere, cheap drinks, and a genuine sense of community.
The Full Cup
This local favorite has been around for years and is a popular place to get a drink with friends on Staten Island.
Cargo Cafe
With live music events, this waterfront dive bar offers a fun environment to enjoy on Staten Island.
Snug Harbor Tavern
Enjoy live music, dancing, and an overall good time with friends at this Staten Island bar.
Staten Island’s Best Bars with Live Music
For music lovers, Staten Island offers a variety of bars that feature live music, from local bands to established acts. These spots are perfect for enjoying a night of entertainment while sipping on your favorite drink.
South Shore Bar & Grill
Known for its live music and lively atmosphere, South Shore Bar & Grill is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. Enjoy a night of entertainment while enjoying classic bar fare and refreshing drinks. It’s a favorite for its energetic atmosphere and talented musicians.
The Kettle Black
Located in Bay Street, this is a tavern that is known for great bar food and a good time.
Mother Pug’s Irish Pub
With a great local following, this Irish pub is a place that has a great environment to listen to live music and have a good time.
Neighborhood Hangouts: Staten Island’s Classic Pubs
These pubs are the bedrock of Staten Island’s bar scene. They’re the places where regulars gather, locals catch up, and everyone feels welcome. Expect friendly faces, affordable drinks, and a strong sense of community.
The Irish Pub
Classic neighborhood pub with a casual atmosphere, great beer and friendly staff.
The Stone House
Known for its warm atmosphere, The Stone House is a must stop spot on Staten Island for a drink.
Nurnberger Bierhaus
A perfect place to enjoy German beers and a German atmosphere on Staten Island.
Dining and Drinks: Staten Island’s Best Bar & Restaurants
Combining great food with refreshing drinks, these spots provide the perfect atmosphere for a quality night out in Staten Island.
Brothers Pizzeria
With fantastic pizza and a wide selection of drinks, Brothers Pizzeria is a perfect place to have an evening meal on Staten Island.
Casa Franco
This Italian eatery on Staten Island provides a perfect meal and delicious drinks.
Lee Simonson’s
Another great option, this place has the perfect bar with a dining section to have a wonderful time on Staten Island.
Tips for a Great Night Out on Staten Island
Getting around Staten Island is relatively easy. The Staten Island Ferry provides free transportation to and from Manhattan, connecting you to the rest of New York City. From the ferry terminal, you can easily access buses and ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft. If you’re driving, parking can be challenging in some areas, so plan accordingly. As always, be mindful of your surroundings and drink responsibly to ensure a safe and enjoyable night out. Remember to tip your bartenders and servers appropriately and be respectful of the establishments and your fellow patrons.
Your Staten Island Bar Adventure Awaits
Staten Island’s bar scene is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. With its diverse range of establishments, from cozy pubs to upscale lounges, there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor seeking an authentic New York experience, Staten Island’s bars offer a unique and unforgettable night out. So, gather your friends, hop on the ferry, and explore the best sips this underrated borough has to offer. What are your personal favorite Staten Island bars? Share them in the comments below and let us know what makes them so special!
