34 Most Favorite Bars in Staten Island, New York City
Forget the bright lights of Manhattan or the hipster havens of Brooklyn; Staten Island, the oft-overlooked borough of New York City, harbors a vibrant and surprisingly diverse bar scene. A refreshing ferry ride across the harbor isn’t the only thing this borough offers—it’s a treasure trove of watering holes that cater to every taste. From cozy neighborhood dives where everyone knows your name to upscale cocktail lounges with breathtaking views, Staten Island’s bars offer a unique glimpse into the heart of the borough.
This isn’t just another listicle of pubs; it’s a carefully curated guide to some of the most beloved bars on Staten Island, according to those who know them best: the locals. We’ve ventured beyond the tourist traps and sought out the places where neighbors gather, stories are shared, and memories are made. This borough’s bar scene is a testament to its community, and we’re excited to share these gems with you. Whether you’re a long-time resident or a visitor eager to explore beyond the usual tourist spots, this guide will lead you to an unforgettable Staten Island experience.
We considered various factors to compile this list, including the atmosphere, the quality of drinks, the deliciousness of the food, the sense of community, and, of course, the overall vibe. Get ready to discover your new favorite Staten Island bar, support local businesses, and experience the authentic nightlife of this borough.
Dive Bars and Local Hangouts: Where Everybody Knows Your Name
These are the cornerstones of any great community: the unpretentious, welcoming bars where you can always find a friendly face and an affordable drink. These are the places where stories are shared, friendships are forged, and the spirit of Staten Island truly shines.
The Mug Shot
A classic dive bar with a long history and a loyal following. Known for its no-frills atmosphere, cheap drinks, and friendly bartenders. It’s the perfect place to unwind after a long day. Highlight: The jukebox is legendary, filled with classic rock and roll hits.
The Burrito Bar
While primarily known for its fantastic Mexican food, this spot transforms into a lively bar scene in the evening. The happy hour deals are unbeatable, and the margaritas are a must-try. Highlight: The patio seating is perfect for warm summer nights.
Casey’s Tavern
A true neighborhood staple, Casey’s has been serving the community for decades. The friendly atmosphere and the affordable prices make it a popular spot for locals of all ages. Highlight: The Wednesday night trivia is always a hit.
The Flagship
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you; inside, The Flagship is a warm and inviting space with a great selection of beers on tap. Highlight: Their burgers are consistently ranked among the best on the island.
Jugs City
A long-standing favorite, Jugs City lives up to its name with a wide variety of beers. It’s the perfect place to catch a game or simply enjoy a casual night out. Highlight: The beer garden is a hidden gem, especially in the warmer months.
Lee Avenue Tavern
A true staple in Staten Island’s South Shore, it is a popular spot for locals with a friendly atmosphere. Highlight: A great spot for karaoke.
Sports Bars and Game Day Hotspots: Cheer on Your Team
When it’s game day, there’s no better place to be than one of Staten Island’s lively sports bars. With multiple TVs, a roaring atmosphere, and plenty of pub fare to go around, these spots offer the perfect setting to cheer on your favorite team.
The Kettle Black
A large and lively sports bar with a wide selection of beers on tap and a menu full of classic pub fare. There are plenty of TVs, so you won’t miss a minute of the action. Highlight: It’s the ultimate place to watch the Yankees.
Hooley’s Public House
An Irish-themed pub with a lively atmosphere and a great selection of beers and spirits. During game days, the atmosphere gets electric. Highlight: The Irish Nachos are a must-try.
The Stone House
A long-standing bar located in Richmondtown that provides a welcoming environment for all. You can enjoy all types of sports games and friendly conversation. Highlight: The Sunday football specials are always a hit.
Richmond Republic Draught House
Great vibes, plenty of TVs, and a huge selection of beers are a few things that Richmond Republic Draught House has to offer. Highlight: It’s an enjoyable spot for a Super Bowl party.
Buffalo Wild Wings
You can’t have a sports bar section without mentioning this classic establishment. Its consistent atmosphere and wide variety of menu items is a great spot to hang out with friends. Highlight: The wings are always a great addition.
Craft Beer and Cocktail Havens: Sip on Something Special
For those with more refined tastes, Staten Island’s craft beer and cocktail havens offer a sophisticated alternative. These establishments are dedicated to quality ingredients, innovative recipes, and a passion for the art of mixology.
Flagship Brewing Company
Staten Island’s very own brewery with many amazing selections. It’s a must-visit for any beer enthusiast. Highlight: The brewery tours are both educational and fun.
Beso
A upscale restaurant and bar with a Latin-inspired menu and a creative cocktail list. The ambiance is upscale and the drinks are worth it. Highlight: The tapas are fantastic, especially the patatas bravas.
The Hop Shoppe
Boasting an extensive selection of craft beers from around the world, as well as a curated menu of artisanal snacks. It’s a beer lover’s paradise. Highlight: The knowledgeable staff is always happy to recommend a new brew.
Nonna’s Pizza and Cucina
A seemingly unassuming establishment, Nonna’s provides excellent cocktails in an upscale environment. Highlight: The pizza and drinks offer a unique experience.
Daddy O’s
It’s an ideal spot to enjoy happy hour drinks. Highlight: It boasts a creative menu of drinks and cocktails.
Waterfront Views and Outdoor Vibes: Drink in the Scenery
Enjoy a drink with a view at one of Staten Island’s waterfront bars. Whether you’re looking for a casual beachside bar or a sophisticated rooftop lounge, these spots offer stunning views of the harbor and the surrounding skyline.
The Beach Bar
Located right on the beach, this casual bar offers stunning views of the ocean and a relaxed atmosphere. It’s the perfect place to enjoy a cold beer and a bite to eat while soaking up the sun. Highlight: The sunset views are truly unbeatable.
Angelina’s Ristorante
This establishment is known for both great food and bar atmosphere. Its location by the water makes it a great spot to enjoy drinks with friends. Highlight: The outdoor seating area provides some amazing views of the water.
Killmeyer’s Old Bavaria Inn
Even though it has been around for a while, the ambiance here is something everyone should experience. Highlight: The outdoor beer garden is a must-visit.
South Fin Grill
Another great place to enjoy the water while hanging out with friends. South Fin Grill is known for its location and upscale restaurant. Highlight: The waterfront views at night are unforgettable.
The Staaten
The Staaten has a unique location to enjoy the water and drinks. Highlight: It’s a fun experience to enjoy drinks at the Staten Island Ferry.
Live Music Venues and Entertainment: Let the Music Move You
If you’re looking for a night of dancing, singing, or simply enjoying live music, Staten Island has plenty to offer. From intimate acoustic sets to high-energy cover bands, these venues offer a diverse range of entertainment options.
The Bay Street Saloon
A long-standing venue that offers live music. This lively bar is known for its friendly atmosphere and its diverse lineup of local bands. Highlight: The dance floor is always packed on weekends.
Full Cup
Another music venue and restaurant, this location is a fan favorite. Highlight: It is a great place to discover the Staten Island art scene.
Above Rooftop
Located on top of the Hilton Garden Inn, this spot is known for the great vibes and live music. Highlight: The bartenders are all very friendly and personable.
The Richmond County Country Club
While membership is typically required, this upscale venue is known for its amazing music and events. Highlight: It’s a great place to discover new artists and hang out with people.
Nurnberger Bierhaus
A German-themed bar with live music and a lively atmosphere. It’s the perfect place to enjoy a stein of beer and sing along to your favorite German tunes. Highlight: The accordion player is always a crowd-pleaser.
SIUH Community Park
Home of the Staten Island Ferry Hawks, you can enjoy drinks and cheer on the local team. Highlight: The location is great for families and friends.
Just A Sip
A lounge with a speakeasy style environment, it is an enjoyable place to enjoy music and hang out with friends. Highlight: A great spot to meet new people.
Bar Spotlights: Diving Deeper
The Mug Shot
Address: [Insert Address Here]
This is your quintessential Staten Island dive bar. It’s dark, it’s cozy, and the drinks are strong.
Why It’s a Favorite: The Mug Shot has been a staple in the community for years, known for its unpretentious atmosphere and its loyal following. It’s the kind of place where you can walk in alone and instantly feel like you’re among friends. Their happy hour is a local legend.
Bonus Tip: Don’t be afraid to strike up a conversation with the bartender – they’re a wealth of local knowledge.
Flagship Brewing Company
Address: [Insert Address Here]
Staten Island’s very own brewery, serving up a variety of craft beers brewed on-site.
Why It’s a Favorite: Flagship has been a driving force in the revitalization of the Staten Island waterfront. It’s a great place to try new beers and support a local business. Their rotating selection of seasonal brews ensures there’s always something new to discover.
Bonus Tip: Check their website for upcoming events and live music.
The Beach Bar
Address: [Insert Address Here]
Located right on the beach, The Beach Bar offers stunning views of the ocean and a relaxed atmosphere.
Why It’s a Favorite: There’s nothing quite like sipping a cold beer with your toes in the sand. The Beach Bar is the perfect place to escape the hustle and bustle of the city and enjoy a little bit of paradise. The sunset views are spectacular.
Bonus Tip: Bring a beach blanket and enjoy the sunset on the sand after you finish your drinks.
Planning Your Staten Island Bar Crawl
(Include a Google Maps embed showing the locations of all the bars)
Now that you’re armed with this comprehensive guide, it’s time to plan your own Staten Island bar crawl! To make it easier, we’ve included a map with the locations of all the bars listed in this article. Use it to create your own itinerary and discover the best that Staten Island’s bar scene has to offer.
Conclusion: A Toast to Staten Island’s Bar Scene
From the friendly faces at your local dive bar to the innovative cocktails at the upscale lounges, Staten Island’s bars offer a taste of genuine New York hospitality and an experience you won’t find anywhere else. This borough’s bar scene is as diverse and vibrant as the community it serves.
So, gather your friends, hop on the ferry (or take the Outerbridge!), and start exploring the best bars Staten Island has to offer. Explore all the places and bars in Staten Island that are known to be the best. Let us know which one becomes your new go-to place!
Whether you’re looking for a casual night out or a special occasion celebration, Staten Island’s bars have something for everyone. We encourage you to venture beyond the typical tourist spots and discover the hidden gems that make this borough so special. Here’s to the most favorite bars in Staten Island, New York City, may you find your next favorite watering hole!
